June 1996 - Test - lists.nanog.org

Re: leakage of specifics of 204.70.0.0/16
by Peter Lothberg 08 Jun '96

08 Jun '96

ICM-MAE-E>sh ip bgp 204.70.0.0 255.255.0.0 l BGP table version is 5992805, local router ID is 198.67.131.49 Status codes: s suppressed, d damped, h history, * valid, > best, i - internal Origin codes: i - IGP, e - EGP, ? - incomplete Network Next Hop Metric LocPrf Weight Path * i204.70.15.0 144.228.20.11 2 90 0 1239 1790 2638 i * 192.41.177.241 6 90 0 1239 1790 2638 i *>i 144.228.20.11 2 90 0 1239 1790 2638 i *>i204.70.29.0 144.228.20.8 20 90 0 1239 1795 3463 ? * i 144.228.20.8 20 90 0 1239 1795 3463 ? * 192.41.177.241 22 90 0 1239 1795 3463 ? * 204.70.107.0 192.41.177.1 1 90 0 1239 1 5638 ? * 192.41.177.1 41 90 0 1 5638 ? *>i 192.203.229.8 21 90 0 1 5638 ? * i204.70.111.0 192.157.69.9 7 90 0 1239 1793 3857 ? *>i 192.157.69.9 7 90 0 1239 1793 3857 ? * 192.41.177.241 17 90 0 1239 1793 3857 ? * i204.70.128.0/21 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4292 i * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4292 i * 192.41.177.180 1 90 0 1239 3561 4292 i *> 192.41.177.180 90 0 3561 4292 i * 204.70.138.0 192.41.177.180 1 90 0 1239 3561 4281 i *> 192.41.177.180 90 0 3561 4281 i * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4281 i * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4281 i * 204.70.139.0 192.41.177.180 1 90 0 1239 3561 4286 ? *> 192.41.177.180 90 0 3561 4286 ? * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4286 ? * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4286 ? * 204.70.140.0 192.41.177.180 1 90 0 1239 3561 4286 ? *> 192.41.177.180 90 0 3561 4286 ? * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4286 ? * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4286 ? * 204.70.141.0 192.41.177.180 1 90 0 1239 3561 4286 ? *> 192.41.177.180 90 0 3561 4286 ? * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4286 ? * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4286 ? * 204.70.142.0 192.41.177.180 1 90 0 1239 3561 4286 ? *> 192.41.177.180 90 0 3561 4286 ? * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4286 ? * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4286 ? * 204.70.144.0 192.41.177.180 1 90 0 1239 3561 4286 i *> 192.41.177.180 90 0 3561 4286 i * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4286 i * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4286 i * 204.70.145.0 192.41.177.180 1 90 0 1239 3561 4286 ? *> 192.41.177.180 90 0 3561 4286 ? * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4286 ? * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4286 ? *>i204.70.173.0 144.228.20.8 20 90 0 1239 1795 3463 ? * i 144.228.20.8 20 90 0 1239 1795 3463 ? * 192.41.177.241 22 90 0 1239 1795 3463 ? * i204.70.240.0/20 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4292 i * i 192.157.69.11 90 0 3561 4292 i * 192.41.177.180 1 90 0 1239 3561 4292 i *> 192.41.177.180 90 0 3561 4292 i

1 0

leakage of specifics of 204.70.0.0/16
by randy＠psg.com 08 Jun '96

08 Jun '96

i am still trying to understand why this is causing so much of a problem, possibly masking a second bug. but i would appreciate knowing how widespread the leakage is. rg-tig0#sh ip bg 204.70.0.0 255.255.0.0 l BGP table version is 71799, local router ID is 204.70.245.1 Status codes: s suppressed, d damped, h history, * valid, > best, i - internal Origin codes: i - IGP, e - EGP, ? - incomplete Network Next Hop Metric LocPrf Weight Path *> 204.70.0.0/16 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i * 199.2.96.5 1000 0 3130 3561 i *> 204.70.1.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.3.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 ? *> 204.70.6.0/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.6.16/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.6.32/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.6.48/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.6.80/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.6.96/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.6.112/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.6.128/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.6.144/28 204.70.52.25 0 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.6.160/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.15.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.16.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.17.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.18.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.19.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.20.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.21.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.22.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.23.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.24.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.25.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.26.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.27.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.28.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.29.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.30.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.31.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.32.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.33.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.34.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.35.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.36.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.37.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.38.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.39.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.40.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.41.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.42.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.43.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.44.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.45.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.46.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.47.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.48.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.49.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.50.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.51.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.52.0 204.70.52.25 0 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.53.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.54.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.55.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.56.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.57.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.58.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.59.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.60.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.64.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.65.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.66.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.67.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.68.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.69.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.70.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.71.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.72.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.74.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.74.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.74.160/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.74.192/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.75.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.76.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.77.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.78.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.80.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.80.160/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.80.192/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.81.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.82.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.83.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.84.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.86.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.86.160/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.86.192/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.87.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.88.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.89.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.90.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.92.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.92.160/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.92.192/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.93.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.94.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.95.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.96.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.98.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.98.160/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.98.192/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.99.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.100.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.101.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.102.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.104.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.104.160/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.104.192/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.105.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.106.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.107.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.108.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.109.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.110.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.111.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.112.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.114.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.114.160/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.114.192/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.115.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.116.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.117.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.118.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.127.0/29 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.128.0/21 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 4292 i *> 204.70.135.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.138.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 4281 i *> 204.70.139.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 4286 ? *> 204.70.140.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 4286 ? *> 204.70.141.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 4286 ? *> 204.70.142.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 4286 ? *> 204.70.143.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.144.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 4286 i *> 204.70.145.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 4286 ? *> 204.70.152.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.152.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.153.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.154.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.155.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.156.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.158.0/23 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.158.96/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.158.112/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.158.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.158.160/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.158.192/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.159.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.160.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.160.0/23 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.161.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.162.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.164.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.164.160/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.164.192/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.165.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.166.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.167.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.168.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.170.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.170.160/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.170.192/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.171.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.172.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.173.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.174.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.179.96/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.179.112/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.179.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.180.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.181.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.182.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.183.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.185.96/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.185.112/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.185.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.186.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.187.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.188.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.189.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.191.96/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.191.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.192.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.193.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.194.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.195.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.197.96/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.197.112/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.197.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.198.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.199.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.200.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.201.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.203.96/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.203.112/28 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.204.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.205.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.206.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.207.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.208.128/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.208.160/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.208.192/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.208.224/27 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.233.0 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i *> 204.70.240.0/20 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 4292 i *> 204.70.248.0/21 204.70.52.25 1000 0 3561 i

3 4

For those following the Roadrunner v. NSI lawsuit
by Carl Oppedahl 08 Jun '96

08 Jun '96

The case was described in some detail in The Economist, June 8, page 71 in an article entitled "The Internet: Names writ in water". Also, a number of people asked whether the stipulated order relating to NSI's promise not to cut off Roadrunner's domain name was online. It is now online at http://www.patents.com/nsistip.sht . --- Carl Oppedahl, oppedahl(a)patents.com Oppedahl & Larson, patent law firm http://www.patents.com/ is a web server with frequently asked questions and answers on patent law and other intellectual property subjects

1 0

May 1996 notes appearing
by sob＠academ.com 08 Jun '96

08 Jun '96

The notes from the May 1996 are starting to appear at this URL: http://www.academ.com/nanog/may1996 Enjoy.

2 1

Re: Address allocation stats
by bmanning＠isi.edu 07 Jun '96

07 Jun '96

> @ So lets not pick on BBN while the real problem is chomping on our respective > @ hindends. > @ > @ --bill > @ > > Why should anyone even care any more...there are > no good fixes, the people that are in a position to > fix things will never do it...and from an IPv8 point of > view...the entire IPv4 address space is a TWD... > > -- > Jim Fleming > UNETY Systems, Inc. > Naperville, IL > Just curious, How did your missive enter into our TWD of IPv4 anyway and why do you insist on remaining here (unety.net) just to badger us, the poor sots who lack your forsight and vison. I am happy with my heathen ways and don't wish this new religion thrust down my throat. Of course many people I know of who have left IPv4, looked at your IPv8 and decided that it is flawed and moved on.. to IPv10. In fact there are commercial implementations of this code base now from a large number of vendors. Yup, IPX is the wave of the future.... :) -- --bill

1 0

Re: May 1996 notes appearing
by hcb＠clark.net 07 Jun '96

07 Jun '96

>The notes from the May 1996 are starting to appear at this URL: > http://www.academ.com/nanog/may1996 > >Enjoy. I like the part about starting to appear, but I worry now they might disappear periodically. Is this a special case of route flapping? Do we need notes dampening? :-)

1 0

Re: Canadian routes with BGP no-export communities
by Sean Donelan 07 Jun '96

07 Jun '96

>Since the prefix originator is the one who's routing >is breaking, and if they can just register in the RADB to >fix things, I don't really see a problem. That statement isn't true in this case. The more specific networks are registered in the IRR, but what people do and what's in the IRR aren't always related. $ whois -h whois.ra.net 198.53.145 RADB: AS1800, the Sprint 192/2 "default" route object ANS: AS2493, a route object for the specific network with a community ANSIGPONLY AS5765, a route object for the specific network MCI: AS2493, a route object for the specific network AS5765, a route object for the specific network DRA has offices in Canada, so I try to keep up with what's happening with the Canadian networks. I must have missed the announcement about IStar's plans. Since the BGP no-export moves the affect/effect of a broken announcement two AS's away, this might be a good time to bring up the transitive nature of inter-provider NOC communications. What's the value of paying a backbone NOC if the trouble tickets get closed with "not our problem, call A->B->C's NOC yourself." -- Sean Donelan, Data Research Associates, Inc, St. Louis, MO Affiliation given for identification not representation

1 0

MAE-West is up again
by Jake Khuon 07 Jun '96

07 Jun '96

The RS2 machine at MAE-West is once again up. The second machine should be up as well sometime next week. There is still plenty of cleanup to be done and disruptions of service may occur although I will do my best to make sure that does not happen. I would like to personally thank Lance Tatman at NASA, Louis Bamberger and the folks at Sun, and all the rest of those who stayed up through the night for their help in this ordeal. If there are any problems or questions, please feel free to page me at 1-800-635-1868. -- /*====================[ Jake Khuon <khuon(a)Merit.Net> ]=====================+ | Systems Research Programmer, IE Group /| /|[~|)|~|~ N E T W O R K | | Vox: (313) 763-4907 Fax: (313) 747-3185 / |/ |[_|\| | Incorporated | +==[ Suite C2122, Bldg. 1 4251 Plymouth Rd. Ann Arbor, MI 48105-2785 ]==*/

17 32

Re: Address allocation stats
by Paul Ferguson 05 Jun '96

05 Jun '96

Thank you, kind sir. This is exactly what I was looking for: [may '96 figures] Grand Total (Allocated and Assigned Combined) Class A - 127 Class B - 10150 Class C - 764202 Percentage Allocated (Allocated and Assigned Combined) Class A - 100.00% Class B - 61.95% Class C - 36.44% No, back to your regularly scheduled programming. :-) - paul At 10:47 PM 6/4/96 -0400, Mark Kosters wrote: >> Would anyone have a pointer for recent v4 address allocation statistics? >> I'm aware of the Frank's [solensky(a)ftp.com] presentation material >> which he talked about in Los Angeles, but I was looking for something >> a bit more recent, and perhaps HTML'ized. Raw figures welcome. > >The the most recent raw-data report that Frank has based his work on is >available at: > ftp://rs.internic.net/netinfo/ip_network_allocations > >They are generated on a monthly basis and filenames are in the form: > ftp://rs.internic.net/netinfo/ip_network_allocations.YYMmm > >Regards, >Mark > >-- > >Mark Kosters markk(a)internic.net +1 703 742 4795 >Principal Investigator InterNIC Registration Services >PGP Key fingerprint = 1A 2A 92 F8 8E D3 47 F9 15 65 80 87 68 13 F6 48 >

3 4

NEWSFLASH: Joint Venture Announced
by Tim Bass 04 Jun '96

04 Jun '96

>From HPWire: UCSD & GENERAL ATOMICS AGREE TO SUBMIT UNIFIED NSF PROPOSAL ============================================================================= San Diego, Calif. -- The University of California, San Diego (UCSD), and General Atomics (GA) have reached agreement to submit a single, unified proposal by Sept. 3, 1996 to the National Science Foundation program, Partnerships for Advanced Computational Infrastructure (PACI). The announcement, issued last night, appears to resolve recent differences over the future of the San Diego Supercomputer Center (SDSC), a national center for computational science and engineering funded by the National Science Foundation (NSF). (credit: HP Wire Service)

1 0