- NANOG - lists.nanog.org

Re: Incentive for route stabilty
by Justin W. Newton 01 Nov '96

01 Nov '96

At 11:15 AM 11/1/96 -0800, Eric Ziegast wrote: >> Finanical compensation for bgp dampening policies. >> >> Deep pockets = very little flap penalty >> Shallow pockets = very heavy flap penalty > >The main risk (IMHO) when accepting a new peer is how stable the peer >is. Without confidence in the design of the peer's network or trust >in its engineers to prevent/solve problems, connecting to a new peer >with a significant number of routes can be scary. A peer's having >deep pockets usually implies that there's more to lose if they mess >up and that they _might_ want to hire good engineers and pre-plan >their network, but whether they actually do is another story. :^( Well, now that the ra statistics page has information on this sort of thing couldn't that be used as a tool for determining if provider X is doing a good job of keeping their external announcements stable. This is only possible if the person in question has been perring with /someone/ for a reasonable period of time. Justin Newton Network Architect Erol's Internet Services

1 0

The Cidr Report
by Tony Bates 01 Nov '96

01 Nov '96

This is an auto-generated mail on Fri Nov 1 12:00:00 PST 1996 It is not checked before it leaves my workstation. However, hopefully you will find this report interesting and will take the time to look through this to see if you can improve the amount of aggregation you perform. The report is split into sections: 0) General Status List the route table history for the last week, list any possibly bogus routes seen and give some status on ASes. 1) Gains by aggregating at the origin AS level This lists the "Top 30" players who if they decided to aggregate their announced classful prefixes at the origin AS level could make a significant difference in the reduction of the current size of the Internet routing table. This calculation does not take into account the inclusion of holes when forming an aggregate so it is possible even larger reduction should be possible. 2) Weekly Delta A summary of the last weeks changes in terms of withdrawn and added routes. Please note that this is only a snapshot but does give some indication of ASes participating in CIDR. Clearly, it is generally a good thing to see a large amont of withdrawls. 3) Interesting aggregates Interesting here means not an aggregate made as a set of classful routes. Thanks to xara.net for giving me access to their routing tables once a day. Please send any comments about this report directly to me. In the future I hope to put some (or most) of this report up on the web. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CIDR REPORT for 01Nov96 0) General Status Table History ------------- Date Prefixes 261096 41599 271096 41493 281096 41624 291096 42078 301096 42058 311096 41986 011196 41917 Possible Bogus Routes --------------------- *** Bogus 90.0.0.0 from AS4747 AS Summary ---------- Number of ASes in routing system: 1732 Number of ASes announcing only one prefix: 702 (362 cidr, 340 classful) Largest number of cidr routes: 493 announced by AS3561 Largest number of classful routes: 1534 announced by AS174 1) Gains by aggregating at the origin AS level --- 01Nov96 --- ASnum NetsNow NetsCIDR NetGain % Gain Description AS174 1534 1093 441 28.7% Performance Systems International AS3602 621 333 288 46.4% Intergrated Network Services Inc. AS2493 787 500 287 36.5% i*internet AS279 623 401 222 35.6% SURAnet Southern AS AS3397 311 95 216 69.5% EMI-AS AS2048 354 154 200 56.5% State of Louisiana/Office of Tele AS3749 258 60 198 76.7% Tennessee Board of Regents AS1 459 318 141 30.7% BBN Planet backbone AS86 327 195 132 40.4% SURAnet Northern AS AS1691 284 152 132 46.5% BCTEL AS3804 366 240 126 34.4% WorldLinx 3 AS5769 179 71 108 60.3% Le Groupe Videotron Ltee AS560 451 343 108 23.9% BBN Planet, New England Region (N AS813 328 228 100 30.5% UUNET Canada (ASN-UUNETCA-AS1) AS2386 225 133 92 40.9% INS-AS AS568 327 241 86 26.3% JIS (Joint Interconnection Servic AS4230 244 164 80 32.8% Embratel Brazil AS2704 277 198 79 28.5% HOOKUP-NET-A AS2871 165 90 75 45.5% Internet Services GmbH & Co AS3819 101 30 71 70.3% SIGNET AS7195 104 36 68 65.4% INTERRED AS3450 112 47 65 58.0% UTK AS225 118 56 62 52.5% University of Virginia (VIRnet) AS855 132 72 60 45.5% NBTel AS3566 116 56 60 51.7% JRIVER-LINK AS2711 111 54 57 51.4% SUNBELT-AS AS3996 109 53 56 51.4% FIRN AS4454 72 19 53 73.6% OIR Telecommunications, State of AS839 86 38 48 55.8% North West Territories Regional N AS701 799 751 48 6.0% Alternet --- 31Oct96 --- ASnum NetsNow NetsCIDR NetGain % Gain Description AS174 1546 1092 454 29.4% Performance Systems International AS3602 620 332 288 46.5% Intergrated Network Services Inc. AS2493 777 495 282 36.3% i*internet AS279 627 403 224 35.7% SURAnet Southern AS AS3397 310 95 215 69.4% EMI-AS AS2048 354 154 200 56.5% State of Louisiana/Office of Tele AS3749 254 64 190 74.8% Tennessee Board of Regents AS1 457 317 140 30.6% BBN Planet backbone AS1691 291 155 136 46.7% BCTEL AS86 327 195 132 40.4% SURAnet Northern AS AS3804 365 239 126 34.5% WorldLinx 3 AS813 353 243 110 31.2% UUNET Canada (ASN-UUNETCA-AS1) AS5769 179 71 108 60.3% Le Groupe Videotron Ltee AS560 448 340 108 24.1% BBN Planet, New England Region (N AS568 346 247 99 28.6% JIS (Joint Interconnection Servic AS2386 225 133 92 40.9% INS-AS AS4230 242 163 79 32.6% Embratel Brazil AS2704 277 199 78 28.2% HOOKUP-NET-A AS2871 159 87 72 45.3% Internet Services GmbH & Co AS3819 101 30 71 70.3% SIGNET AS3996 118 51 67 56.8% FIRN AS7195 103 38 65 63.1% INTERRED AS3450 113 48 65 57.5% UTK AS225 119 57 62 52.1% University of Virginia (VIRnet) AS3566 115 56 59 51.3% JRIVER-LINK AS855 127 69 58 45.7% NBTel AS2711 111 54 57 51.4% SUNBELT-AS AS4454 72 19 53 73.6% OIR Telecommunications, State of AS701 811 761 50 6.2% Alternet AS839 86 38 48 55.8% North West Territories Regional N --- 30Oct96 --- ASnum NetsNow NetsCIDR NetGain % Gain Description AS174 1565 1102 463 29.6% Performance Systems International AS2493 776 494 282 36.3% i*internet AS3602 608 328 280 46.1% Intergrated Network Services Inc. AS279 625 398 227 36.3% SURAnet Southern AS AS3397 309 99 210 68.0% EMI-AS AS2048 354 154 200 56.5% State of Louisiana/Office of Tele AS3749 257 60 197 76.7% Tennessee Board of Regents AS1 453 313 140 30.9% BBN Planet backbone AS1691 287 155 132 46.0% BCTEL AS86 326 195 131 40.2% SURAnet Northern AS AS3804 366 240 126 34.4% WorldLinx 3 AS813 353 244 109 30.9% UUNET Canada (ASN-UUNETCA-AS1) AS5769 178 70 108 60.7% Le Groupe Videotron Ltee AS560 449 341 108 24.1% BBN Planet, New England Region (N AS568 347 249 98 28.2% JIS (Joint Interconnection Servic AS2386 226 134 92 40.7% INS-AS AS2871 181 99 82 45.3% Internet Services GmbH & Co AS2704 278 199 79 28.4% HOOKUP-NET-A AS4230 239 164 75 31.4% Embratel Brazil AS3819 101 30 71 70.3% SIGNET AS7195 105 37 68 64.8% INTERRED AS3996 119 53 66 55.5% FIRN AS3450 113 48 65 57.5% UTK AS3566 118 54 64 54.2% JRIVER-LINK AS855 132 69 63 47.7% NBTel AS225 119 57 62 52.1% University of Virginia (VIRnet) AS2711 111 54 57 51.4% SUNBELT-AS AS5650 165 110 55 33.3% Electric Lightwave Inc. and XMiss AS4454 64 12 52 81.2% OIR Telecommunications, State of AS701 807 757 50 6.2% Alternet --- 29Oct96 --- ASnum NetsNow NetsCIDR NetGain % Gain Description AS174 1251 913 338 27.0% Performance Systems International AS2493 776 494 282 36.3% i*internet AS3602 610 330 280 45.9% Intergrated Network Services Inc. AS279 622 401 221 35.5% SURAnet Southern AS AS3397 309 95 214 69.3% EMI-AS AS2048 351 158 193 55.0% State of Louisiana/Office of Tele AS3749 251 65 186 74.1% Tennessee Board of Regents AS1 445 308 137 30.8% BBN Planet backbone AS1691 289 156 133 46.0% BCTEL AS86 324 197 127 39.2% SURAnet Northern AS AS3804 362 236 126 34.8% WorldLinx 3 AS560 448 340 108 24.1% BBN Planet, New England Region (N AS813 352 245 107 30.4% UUNET Canada (ASN-UUNETCA-AS1) AS2871 200 93 107 53.5% Internet Services GmbH & Co AS5769 175 69 106 60.6% Le Groupe Videotron Ltee AS568 348 248 100 28.7% JIS (Joint Interconnection Servic AS2386 226 134 92 40.7% INS-AS AS2704 274 192 82 29.9% HOOKUP-NET-A AS4230 234 162 72 30.8% Embratel Brazil AS3819 101 30 71 70.3% SIGNET AS5650 192 122 70 36.5% Electric Lightwave Inc. and XMiss AS3450 113 48 65 57.5% UTK AS855 132 69 63 47.7% NBTel AS7195 97 35 62 63.9% INTERRED AS225 119 57 62 52.1% University of Virginia (VIRnet) AS3996 116 55 61 52.6% FIRN AS3566 117 56 61 52.1% JRIVER-LINK AS3575 74 14 60 81.1% Seanet, Inc AS2711 111 54 57 51.4% SUNBELT-AS AS4454 64 12 52 81.2% OIR Telecommunications, State of --- 28Oct96 --- ASnum NetsNow NetsCIDR NetGain % Gain Description AS174 1251 913 338 27.0% Performance Systems International AS2493 776 494 282 36.3% i*internet AS3602 610 330 280 45.9% Intergrated Network Services Inc. AS279 622 401 221 35.5% SURAnet Southern AS AS3397 309 95 214 69.3% EMI-AS AS2048 351 158 193 55.0% State of Louisiana/Office of Tele AS3749 251 65 186 74.1% Tennessee Board of Regents AS1 445 308 137 30.8% BBN Planet backbone AS1691 289 156 133 46.0% BCTEL AS86 324 197 127 39.2% SURAnet Northern AS AS3804 362 236 126 34.8% WorldLinx 3 AS560 448 340 108 24.1% BBN Planet, New England Region (N AS813 352 245 107 30.4% UUNET Canada (ASN-UUNETCA-AS1) AS2871 200 93 107 53.5% Internet Services GmbH & Co AS5769 175 69 106 60.6% Le Groupe Videotron Ltee AS568 348 248 100 28.7% JIS (Joint Interconnection Servic AS2386 226 134 92 40.7% INS-AS AS2704 274 192 82 29.9% HOOKUP-NET-A AS4230 234 162 72 30.8% Embratel Brazil AS3819 101 30 71 70.3% SIGNET AS5650 192 122 70 36.5% Electric Lightwave Inc. and XMiss AS3450 113 48 65 57.5% UTK AS855 132 69 63 47.7% NBTel AS7195 97 35 62 63.9% INTERRED AS225 119 57 62 52.1% University of Virginia (VIRnet) AS3996 116 55 61 52.6% FIRN AS3566 117 56 61 52.1% JRIVER-LINK AS3575 74 14 60 81.1% Seanet, Inc AS2711 111 54 57 51.4% SUNBELT-AS AS4454 64 12 52 81.2% OIR Telecommunications, State of --- 27Oct96 --- ASnum NetsNow NetsCIDR NetGain % Gain Description AS174 1271 933 338 26.6% Performance Systems International AS2493 771 489 282 36.6% i*internet AS3602 611 330 281 46.0% Intergrated Network Services Inc. AS279 621 399 222 35.7% SURAnet Southern AS AS3397 309 95 214 69.3% EMI-AS AS2048 350 157 193 55.1% State of Louisiana/Office of Tele AS3749 250 67 183 73.2% Tennessee Board of Regents AS1 443 306 137 30.9% BBN Planet backbone AS1691 286 156 130 45.5% BCTEL AS3804 357 233 124 34.7% WorldLinx 3 AS86 303 183 120 39.6% SURAnet Northern AS AS813 354 246 108 30.5% UUNET Canada (ASN-UUNETCA-AS1) AS560 447 339 108 24.2% BBN Planet, New England Region (N AS2871 200 93 107 53.5% Internet Services GmbH & Co AS5769 175 69 106 60.6% Le Groupe Videotron Ltee AS568 347 249 98 28.2% JIS (Joint Interconnection Servic AS2386 226 134 92 40.7% INS-AS AS2704 277 195 82 29.6% HOOKUP-NET-A AS4230 234 160 74 31.6% Embratel Brazil AS3819 101 30 71 70.3% SIGNET AS5650 192 122 70 36.5% Electric Lightwave Inc. and XMiss AS7195 98 34 64 65.3% INTERRED AS855 131 68 63 48.1% NBTel AS225 119 57 62 52.1% University of Virginia (VIRnet) AS3996 116 55 61 52.6% FIRN AS3566 117 56 61 52.1% JRIVER-LINK AS3575 74 14 60 81.1% Seanet, Inc AS3450 109 51 58 53.2% UTK AS2711 111 54 57 51.4% SUNBELT-AS AS4454 64 12 52 81.2% OIR Telecommunications, State of --- 26Oct96 --- ASnum NetsNow NetsCIDR NetGain % Gain Description AS174 1277 935 342 26.8% Performance Systems International AS3602 625 334 291 46.6% Intergrated Network Services Inc. AS2493 770 491 279 36.2% i*internet AS279 622 400 222 35.7% SURAnet Southern AS AS3397 308 94 214 69.5% EMI-AS AS2048 350 160 190 54.3% State of Louisiana/Office of Tele AS3749 254 65 189 74.4% Tennessee Board of Regents AS1 452 312 140 31.0% BBN Planet backbone AS1691 281 150 131 46.6% BCTEL AS86 324 197 127 39.2% SURAnet Northern AS AS3804 362 236 126 34.8% WorldLinx 3 AS813 353 246 107 30.3% UUNET Canada (ASN-UUNETCA-AS1) AS5769 175 69 106 60.6% Le Groupe Videotron Ltee AS560 445 339 106 23.8% BBN Planet, New England Region (N AS2871 195 92 103 52.8% Internet Services GmbH & Co AS568 347 249 98 28.2% JIS (Joint Interconnection Servic AS2386 226 134 92 40.7% INS-AS AS2704 278 196 82 29.5% HOOKUP-NET-A AS4230 229 157 72 31.4% Embratel Brazil AS3819 101 30 71 70.3% SIGNET AS5650 192 122 70 36.5% Electric Lightwave Inc. and XMiss AS3450 113 48 65 57.5% UTK AS7195 98 34 64 65.3% INTERRED AS3566 118 54 64 54.2% JRIVER-LINK AS855 132 69 63 47.7% NBTel AS225 119 57 62 52.1% University of Virginia (VIRnet) AS3996 115 54 61 53.0% FIRN AS2711 112 55 57 50.9% SUNBELT-AS AS3575 73 17 56 76.7% Seanet, Inc AS4454 64 12 52 81.2% OIR Telecommunications, State of --- 25Oct96 --- ASnum NetsNow NetsCIDR NetGain % Gain Description AS174 1270 935 335 26.4% Performance Systems International AS3602 625 334 291 46.6% Intergrated Network Services Inc. AS2493 772 492 280 36.3% i*internet AS3301 836 574 262 31.3% TeliaNet Sweden AS279 617 401 216 35.0% SURAnet Southern AS AS3397 309 95 214 69.3% EMI-AS AS2048 352 161 191 54.3% State of Louisiana/Office of Tele AS3749 247 69 178 72.1% Tennessee Board of Regents AS1 449 310 139 31.0% BBN Planet backbone AS1691 292 157 135 46.2% BCTEL AS86 326 198 128 39.3% SURAnet Northern AS AS3804 361 235 126 34.9% WorldLinx 3 AS5769 176 65 111 63.1% Le Groupe Videotron Ltee AS813 355 245 110 31.0% UUNET Canada (ASN-UUNETCA-AS1) AS560 444 337 107 24.1% BBN Planet, New England Region (N AS2871 200 93 107 53.5% Internet Services GmbH & Co AS568 345 248 97 28.1% JIS (Joint Interconnection Servic AS2386 227 135 92 40.5% INS-AS AS2704 277 198 79 28.5% HOOKUP-NET-A AS4230 234 161 73 31.2% Embratel Brazil AS3819 101 30 71 70.3% SIGNET AS5650 192 122 70 36.5% Electric Lightwave Inc. and XMiss AS7195 104 38 66 63.5% INTERRED AS3996 118 53 65 55.1% FIRN AS3450 113 48 65 57.5% UTK AS3575 80 18 62 77.5% Seanet, Inc AS225 118 56 62 52.5% University of Virginia (VIRnet) AS855 132 71 61 46.2% NBTel AS2711 111 54 57 51.4% SUNBELT-AS AS4454 64 12 52 81.2% OIR Telecommunications, State of 2) Weekly Delta This a daily snapshot of changes in classful routes being withdrawn and added. the deltas are calculated over a rolling 7 day period. Please bear in mind this is purely a "snapshot" and a large flucuation could be caused by a connectivity problem for example. However, this does give some indication of service providers that are moving to classless routing. Top 20 Withdrawn Routes from 25Oct96 to 01Nov96 -570 AS3301 TeliaNet Sweden -69 AS3575 Seanet, Inc -50 AS297 NASA Internet -46 AS5650 Electric Lightwave Inc. and XMiss -42 AS1263 NSN-TEST-AS -40 AS1749 NASA-GSFC-AS -35 AS2871 Internet Services GmbH & Co -34 AS1262 NSN-NCAR-AS-AS -32 AS4239 Coast to Coast Telecommunications -29 AS2500 WIDE Internet AS -27 AS813 UUNET Canada (ASN-UUNETCA-AS1) -26 AS6381 AS 6381 Object -22 AS6498 INTERCALL -21 AS4628 Pacific Internet ASN -20 AS3559 KORNET-3559 Autonomous-system -19 AS3215 RAIN -18 AS568 JIS (Joint Interconnection Servic -15 AS3491 CAIS-ASN -11 AS701 Alternet -10 AS6521 AROSNET Top 20 Added Routes from 25Oct96 to 01Nov96 264 AS174 Performance Systems International 30 AS6285 EN-AS 26 AS6912 Hayes Computer Systems, Inc. 19 AS7035 ECLIPSE 17 AS3566 JRIVER-LINK 15 AS376 RISQ Backbone 14 AS2860 IP Global, Informatica e Telecomu 13 AS400 AFCONC-BLOCK1-AS 12 AS3255 Ukrainian Academic and Research N 11 AS3749 Tennessee Board of Regents 10 AS4230 Embratel Brazil 9 AS3561 MCI 8 AS4454 OIR Telecommunications, State of 7 AS4747 APNIC-AS-BLOCK 6 AS3354 THENET-AS-1 5 AS3804 WorldLinx 3 4 AS1323 ANS Chicago - DNSS 27 3 AS816 UUNETCA-AS4 2 AS2119 TelePost Internet 1 AS22 NOSC (Naval Ocean Systems Center) 3) Interesting aggregates List of possibly interesting aggregates --------------------------------------- aggregate origin-AS AS Description 9.2.0.0/16 AS1747 IBM Watson, Yorktown Heights, 9.20.0.0/17 AS2686 Autonomous System number for I 9.67.0.0/19 AS3561 MCI 12.0.0.0/9 AS7018 AT&T worldnet network 57.12.0.0/16 AS5384 Etisalat Emirates Internet 128.145.228.0/24 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 128.167.7.0/24 AS86 SURAnet Northern AS 128.188.1.0/24 AS560 BBN Planet, New England Region 129.181.216.0/22 AS517 Xlink 130.168.105.0/24 AS1270 EUnet Germany 130.168.115.0/24 AS1270 EUnet Germany 130.168.125.0/24 AS1270 EUnet Germany 130.188.2.0/24 AS565 VTT autonomous system 130.188.3.0/24 AS565 VTT autonomous system 130.188.150.0/24 AS565 VTT autonomous system 130.188.250.0/24 AS565 VTT autonomous system 130.188.252.0/24 AS565 VTT autonomous system 130.205.64.0/18 AS3561 MCI 130.252.178.0/24 AS1321 ANS San Francisco - DNSS 11 131.114.192.0/18 AS2598 Consiglio Nazionale delle Rice 131.117.0.0/17 AS559 SWITCH, Swiss Academic and Res 132.235.204.0/24 AS3561 MCI 134.6.160.0/22 AS2706 HKSUPER 134.6.180.0/24 AS2706 HKSUPER 134.33.100.0/24 AS701 Alternet 134.129.64.0/18 AS6263 NDIN 134.133.184.0/24 AS2548 DIGEX-AS 134.198.8.0/21 AS3593 Eastern Pennsylvania Internet 134.198.16.0/21 AS3593 Eastern Pennsylvania Internet 134.198.24.0/21 AS3593 Eastern Pennsylvania Internet 134.198.32.0/21 AS3593 Eastern Pennsylvania Internet 134.198.40.0/21 AS3593 Eastern Pennsylvania Internet 134.198.48.0/21 AS3593 Eastern Pennsylvania Internet 134.198.56.0/21 AS3593 Eastern Pennsylvania Internet 134.198.64.0/21 AS3593 Eastern Pennsylvania Internet 134.198.72.0/21 AS3593 Eastern Pennsylvania Internet 134.198.96.0/21 AS3593 Eastern Pennsylvania Internet 134.198.168.0/21 AS3593 Eastern Pennsylvania Internet 134.198.192.0/21 AS3593 Eastern Pennsylvania Internet 134.198.232.0/21 AS3593 Eastern Pennsylvania Internet 134.198.240.0/21 AS3593 Eastern Pennsylvania Internet 134.241.109.0/24 AS560 BBN Planet, New England Region 135.14.65.0/24 AS3111 Internet Direct Inc. (ASN-DIRE 135.16.150.0/24 AS560 BBN Planet, New England Region 136.140.9.0/24 AS3561 MCI 137.62.197.0/24 AS1794 SprintLink Pennsauken NJ 138.95.80.0/24 AS701 Alternet 138.108.100.0/24 AS3561 MCI 138.182.252.0/24 AS5855 Secretary of the Navy 138.182.254.0/24 AS5855 Secretary of the Navy 139.46.35.0/24 AS560 BBN Planet, New England Region 139.61.102.0/24 AS3111 Internet Direct Inc. (ASN-DIRE 139.61.103.0/24 AS3111 Internet Direct Inc. (ASN-DIRE 139.162.128.0/17 AS1136 Unisource Internet Service NL 140.188.33.0/24 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 140.188.64.0/24 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 140.188.86.0/24 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 140.188.129.0/24 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 140.188.148.0/24 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 140.188.198.0/24 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 140.188.246.0/24 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 140.188.248.0/24 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 140.231.44.0/24 AS3561 MCI 141.227.111.0/24 AS2529 Demon Internet Ltd 142.218.120.0/24 AS2551 NETCOM On-line Communication S 143.93.32.0/19 AS517 Xlink 143.222.116.0/24 AS3407 Interpath 143.252.80.0/24 AS2856 BTnet UK Regional network 144.127.110.0/23 AS2707 WEC 144.127.112.0/20 AS2707 WEC 144.127.128.0/19 AS2707 WEC 144.127.160.0/21 AS2707 WEC 144.127.168.0/23 AS2707 WEC 144.192.181.0/24 AS4200 AGIS (Apex Global Information 144.199.161.0/24 AS1238 ICM Malaysia (MIMOS) connectee 145.17.100.0/24 AS2856 BTnet UK Regional network 145.72.32.0/19 AS5484 BT Netherlands Regional Servic 145.72.64.0/19 AS5484 BT Netherlands Regional Servic 145.246.16.0/24 AS2856 BTnet UK Regional network 145.246.17.0/24 AS2856 BTnet UK Regional network 145.247.128.0/18 AS2120 DAXnet (Tele 3) 145.248.112.0/24 AS2706 HKSUPER 145.248.155.0/24 AS2706 HKSUPER 145.248.157.0/24 AS2706 HKSUPER 145.248.159.0/24 AS2706 HKSUPER 145.248.161.0/24 AS2706 HKSUPER 145.248.165.0/24 AS2706 HKSUPER 146.75.251.0/24 AS3301 TeliaNet Sweden 146.75.253.0/24 AS1257 SWIPnet Swedish IP Network 146.75.254.0/24 AS3301 TeliaNet Sweden 146.192.0.0/17 AS2119 TelePost Internet 146.193.60.0/22 AS2860 IP Global, Informatica e Telec 147.85.21.0/24 AS3951 ICONNET 147.85.25.0/24 AS3951 ICONNET 147.85.39.0/24 AS3951 ICONNET 147.85.44.0/24 AS3951 ICONNET 147.85.51.0/24 AS3951 ICONNET 147.85.115.0/24 AS3951 ICONNET 147.160.0.0/17 AS3561 MCI 147.160.128.0/18 AS3561 MCI 147.160.200.0/21 AS3561 MCI 147.160.208.0/20 AS3561 MCI 147.160.224.0/20 AS3561 MCI 147.206.20.0/24 AS3561 MCI 148.59.2.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.4.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.14.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.15.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.16.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.18.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.19.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.224.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.228.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.229.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.234.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.237.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.238.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.241.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.244.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.246.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.59.250.0/24 AS2015 Msen, Inc. 148.94.210.0/24 AS5714 EDS-WEBS 148.185.45.0/24 AS1849 PIPEX, Public IP EXchange 148.252.1.0/24 AS1849 PIPEX, Public IP EXchange 149.20.4.0/24 AS1239 SprintLink Backbone 149.20.64.0/24 AS701 Alternet 149.212.64.0/20 AS1759 Telecom Finland iNET 149.236.92.0/24 AS6292 FCI 150.100.52.0/24 AS1792 SprintLink Stockton CA 150.185.128.0/18 AS1800 ICM-Atlantic 150.185.192.0/18 AS1800 ICM-Atlantic 150.207.2.0/24 AS1221 AARNET-AS 150.207.128.0/24 AS2764 CONNECT-NET 152.129.186.0/24 AS4478 PNET-STL 152.175.128.0/17 AS1667 ANS-BLK1 152.179.0.0/17 AS1321 ANS San Francisco - DNSS 11 152.181.128.0/17 AS-set UNKNOWN 152.181.184.0/22 AS1667 ANS-BLK1 152.187.0.0/17 AS1321 ANS San Francisco - DNSS 11 152.189.128.0/17 AS1327 ANS Washington D.C. - DNSS 59 152.189.184.0/22 AS1667 ANS-BLK1 153.96.80.0/21 AS517 Xlink 153.96.92.0/24 AS517 Xlink 153.96.188.0/22 AS517 Xlink 153.96.230.0/24 AS517 Xlink 154.11.1.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.2.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.8.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.8.0/21 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.16.0/24 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 154.11.16.0/21 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.24.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.24.0/21 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.25.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.32.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.32.0/20 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.36.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.37.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.48.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.48.0/20 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.64.0/24 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 154.11.64.0/20 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.96.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.96.0/21 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.97.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.98.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.99.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.108.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.108.0/22 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.109.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.110.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.120.0/21 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.126.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 154.11.127.0/24 AS8013 PSINET-CA 155.39.191.0/24 AS2685 IBM Global Network - US 155.134.60.0/24 AS701 Alternet 155.140.124.0/24 AS1849 PIPEX, Public IP EXchange 155.203.254.0/24 AS3561 MCI 155.229.120.0/21 AS4565 HLC Internet 155.229.176.0/21 AS7045 WEATHER 156.51.204.0/24 AS3301 TeliaNet Sweden 156.114.200.0/24 AS2529 Demon Internet Ltd 157.184.150.0/24 AS1330 ANS St. Louis - DNSS 83 157.232.100.0/24 AS3561 MCI 158.43.200.0/24 AS701 Alternet 158.118.51.0/24 AS701 Alternet 158.146.44.0/24 AS1791 SprintLink Fort Worth TX 158.146.172.0/24 AS1791 SprintLink Fort Worth TX 158.146.180.0/24 AS1791 SprintLink Fort Worth TX 158.155.24.0/22 AS1221 AARNET-AS 158.174.254.0/24 AS2856 BTnet UK Regional network 159.24.7.0/24 AS4286 IMCI 159.87.34.0/24 AS200 BBN Planet Western Region 159.179.0.0/24 AS3561 MCI 159.197.158.0/23 AS2529 Demon Internet Ltd 159.245.84.0/22 AS1849 PIPEX, Public IP EXchange 159.245.104.0/22 AS1849 PIPEX, Public IP EXchange 160.92.129.0/24 AS2917 OLEANE - PIPEX International 160.104.0.0/17 AS701 Alternet 160.104.128.0/17 AS1290 PSINet UK Ltd. 161.6.0.0/17 AS3561 MCI 161.6.128.0/17 AS3561 MCI 161.22.0.0/24 AS1790 SprintLink Washington D.C. 161.51.224.0/20 AS1849 PIPEX, Public IP EXchange 161.52.192.0/19 AS2845 SUNET-LUND 161.120.6.0/24 AS3561 MCI 161.173.243.0/24 AS2386 INS-AS 161.223.220.0/22 AS1 BBN Planet backbone 161.223.224.0/24 AS1 BBN Planet backbone 162.17.253.0/24 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 162.81.141.0/24 AS3561 MCI 163.12.0.0/23 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.5.0/24 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.6.0/23 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.8.0/21 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.16.0/22 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.21.0/24 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.22.0/24 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.22.0/23 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.23.0/24 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.24.0/21 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.32.0/19 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.64.0/20 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.64.0/18 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.81.0/24 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.82.0/23 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.84.0/22 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.88.0/21 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.96.0/19 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.128.0/21 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.136.0/22 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.144.0/20 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.160.0/19 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.192.0/21 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.12.240.0/20 AS3576 PREPnet-EAST 163.44.224.0/21 AS4853 Justsystem Corporation 163.44.240.0/21 AS4853 Justsystem Corporation 163.49.131.0/24 AS3561 MCI 163.49.132.0/22 AS3561 MCI 163.49.136.0/22 AS3561 MCI 163.49.140.0/23 AS3561 MCI 163.49.142.0/24 AS3561 MCI 163.168.212.0/24 AS3303 Unisource Business Networks (S 163.249.43.0/24 AS3739 NEWNET 163.249.53.0/24 AS3739 NEWNET 163.249.54.0/24 AS3739 NEWNET 163.249.57.0/24 AS3739 NEWNET 163.249.140.0/22 AS3739 NEWNET 163.249.160.0/21 AS3739 NEWNET 163.249.168.0/24 AS3739 NEWNET 163.249.169.0/24 AS3739 NEWNET 163.249.170.0/24 AS3739 NEWNET 164.52.249.0/24 AS1982 Northwest Nexus, Inc. 164.53.55.0/24 AS2706 HKSUPER 164.100.64.0/20 AS3561 MCI 164.100.81.0/24 AS3561 MCI 164.100.82.0/23 AS3561 MCI 164.100.84.0/22 AS3561 MCI 164.100.88.0/21 AS3561 MCI 164.100.96.0/19 AS3561 MCI 164.100.167.0/24 AS3561 MCI 164.100.199.0/24 AS4755 Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd. Indi 164.103.3.0/24 AS3561 MCI 164.224.208.0/20 AS5855 Secretary of the Navy 165.108.130.0/24 AS3561 MCI 165.108.130.0/23 AS3561 MCI 165.108.132.0/22 AS3561 MCI 165.108.136.0/21 AS3561 MCI 165.108.144.0/22 AS3561 MCI 165.108.148.0/23 AS3561 MCI 165.113.197.0/24 AS6006 UNKNOWN 165.113.198.0/24 AS6006 UNKNOWN 165.113.199.0/24 AS6006 UNKNOWN 165.113.211.0/24 AS6006 UNKNOWN 165.113.219.0/24 AS6006 UNKNOWN 165.166.123.0/24 AS3561 MCI 165.215.64.0/18 AS4183 CompuServe, Incorporated 165.215.191.0/24 AS5090 CWI-NYD 165.247.33.0/24 AS5696 Primary AS for GoodNet 165.247.47.0/24 AS5696 Primary AS for GoodNet 165.247.77.0/24 AS5696 Primary AS for GoodNet 166.38.40.0/24 AS3561 MCI 166.147.0.0/18 AS3561 MCI 166.147.64.0/18 AS3561 MCI 166.147.128.0/18 AS3561 MCI 166.147.192.0/18 AS3561 MCI 166.150.0.0/18 AS3561 MCI 166.150.64.0/18 AS3561 MCI 166.150.128.0/18 AS3561 MCI 166.150.192.0/18 AS3561 MCI 166.151.0.0/18 AS3561 MCI 166.151.64.0/18 AS3561 MCI 166.151.128.0/18 AS3561 MCI 167.170.6.0/23 AS3313 I.Net S.p.A. 167.170.32.0/23 AS3313 I.Net S.p.A. 167.208.125.0/24 AS3561 MCI 168.14.1.0/24 AS3561 MCI 168.14.2.0/23 AS3561 MCI 168.14.4.0/22 AS3561 MCI 168.14.8.0/21 AS3561 MCI 168.14.16.0/20 AS3561 MCI 168.29.0.0/17 AS3492 ATLANTA 168.97.37.0/24 AS3561 MCI 168.175.70.0/24 AS3561 MCI 168.175.170.0/24 AS3561 MCI 168.175.171.0/24 AS3561 MCI 168.175.172.0/24 AS3561 MCI 168.224.128.0/24 AS2856 BTnet UK Regional network 168.247.253.0/24 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 168.247.254.0/24 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 169.137.170.0/24 AS3407 Interpath 169.200.1.0/24 AS3561 MCI 170.115.249.0/24 AS4969 Net Access 170.194.51.0/24 AS1849 PIPEX, Public IP EXchange 170.204.82.0/23 AS1791 SprintLink Fort Worth TX 170.204.84.0/24 AS1791 SprintLink Fort Worth TX 171.18.1.0/24 AS3215 RAIN 171.25.128.0/20 AS3301 TeliaNet Sweden 171.25.128.0/19 AS3301 TeliaNet Sweden 171.25.144.0/21 AS3301 TeliaNet Sweden 171.25.152.0/21 AS3301 TeliaNet Sweden 171.30.170.0/24 AS2856 BTnet UK Regional network 194.23.1.36/30 AS3305 Internet Service Provider back 194.178.245.32/28 AS5417 Demon Internet Ltd 194.237.174.32/27 AS3308 TeliaNet Denmark 199.99.247.32/27 AS174 Performance Systems Internatio 199.233.98.0/25 AS6082 MAI Network Services 199.233.98.128/25 AS6082 MAI Network Services 202.50.137.64/27 AS2687 IBM Global Network - AP 204.148.62.0/26 AS1673 ANS-BLK1 205.156.223.176/28 AS2702 Spry AS

1 0

the resolution [was: Re: AGIS v BBN]
by Peter Kline 01 Nov '96

01 Nov '96

Turns out that our problem at Pennsauken boils down to netflow switching on FDDI interfaces being broken under 11.1.6, and 11.1.7 also. Cisco will be creating a bug for this. The AGIS Pennsauken router is now functional and back on the net and moving more traffic than it ever did before. Peter At 01:16 PM 11/1/96 -0500, Pritish Shah wrote: >this is not due to AGIS vs BBN. This is plain and simple BBN that is not >ok. As the response from one of the bbnplanet employee, the DNS is setup >but there is not machine at that location. > >Pritish > >On Fri, 1 Nov 1996, Kent W. England wrote: > >> Folks; >> >> It appears that routes to BBN via AGIS aren't working but others are. Is >> this true? Perhaps we should start an AGIS Peering Woes List? >> >> 1) Digex >> 2) BBN Planet >> 3) ?? >> >> --Kent >> >> > > >

1 0

BBN bitten again?
by Kent W. England 01 Nov '96

01 Nov '96

Folks; Since early yesterday, much or all of BBN Cambridge has been down. Anyone know what is going on? More rodent adventures? Or did that gasoline truck I fantasized about really turn over into the parking level? --Kent TraceRoute noc.bbnplanet.com (199.94.209.25) timed out 1 292 292 205.163.24.49 nb49.cts.com 2 278 -14 205.163.24.33 ctshub-e1.cts.com 3 332 54 207.67.240.113 cts-gw-ds3.atmnet.net 4 306 -26 206.62.12.49 agis-atmnet.losangeles.agis.net 5 293 -13 205.254.168.249 a5-0.1009.santaclara3.agis.net 6 288 -5 198.32.136.14 mae-w.bbnplanet.net 7 277 -11 4.0.20.17 sanjose1-br2.bbnplanet.net 8 295 18 4.0.1.81 sanjose1-br1.bbnplanet.net 9 309 14 4.0.1.73 oakland-br2.bbnplanet.net 10 319 10 4.0.1.134 denver-br1.bbnplanet.net 11 313 -6 4.0.1.134 denver-br1.bbnplanet.net 12 323 10 4.0.1.190 denver-br2.bbnplanet.net 13 336 13 4.0.1.130 chicago1-br1.bbnplanet.net 14 407 71 4.0.1.194 chicago1-br2.bbnplanet.net 15 381 -26 4.0.1.126 boston1-br1.bbnplanet.net 16 613 232 4.0.1.182 boston1-br2.bbnplanet.net 17 1752 1139 4.0.1.158 cambridge1-br2.bbnplanet.net 18 * * timed out 19 * * timed out 20 * * timed out 21 * * timed out 22 * * timed out 23 * * timed out 24 * * timed out 25 * * timed out 26 * * timed out 27 * * timed out 28 * * timed out 29 * * timed out 30 * * timed out not reached

7 6

Settlement Costs
by William Allen Simpson 01 Nov '96

01 Nov '96

> Date: Wed, 30 Oct 1996 17:31:39 -0500 > From: Scott Huddle <huddle(a)mci.net> > Your argument changes from an economic one to a political one. If > you want to run for office, there are better forums. If you want > to convince people who are building commercial networks, get > some facts. > In your reply to Dillon, you accuse him of having inaccurate figures. Now, the fact is, he's probably not been around long enough to have read the report, that has long since entered into the net consciousness. I remember seeing it about 5-6 years ago. I think it was a BellCore study, but I may be misremembering. It concluded that over half the cost of operating the RBOCs was customer billing. As I remember, it in turn was based on the reported figures to the PUCs of the RBOCs, looking at the depreciated cost of the cable plant, the stated cost of yearly plant maintenance, and the proportion of equipment unrelated to billing. As I remember, virtually all the switch maintenance costs (particularly configuration and software) was unit billing related. All the customer service reps and such were assumed billing related, while directory service operations were not. Then, proportion the management cost accordingly, and assumed that everything else is billing related. Now, that may have been an old report. I'm sure MCI would be delighted to reveal its current figures for plant depreciation and maintenance, and the amount that it pays (the RBOCs) for unit timing and printing and mailing the statements, along with all the payment collection costs. When you are ready to send that to this list, I will accept your further criticism here of Dillon's numbers. Thank you. WSimpson(a)UMich.edu Key fingerprint = 17 40 5E 67 15 6F 31 26 DD 0D B9 9B 6A 15 2C 32 BSimpson(a)MorningStar.com Key fingerprint = 2E 07 23 03 C5 62 70 D3 59 B1 4F 5E 1D C2 C1 A2

2 2

Incentive for route stabilty
by Scott Mace 01 Nov '96

01 Nov '96

Here's an idea that just popped into my head after NANOG. Lets assume for a moment that the majority of route instabilty is coming from inexperienced providers. With that assumption in hand I propose the following incentive: Finanical compensation for bgp dampening policies. Deep pockets = very little flap penalty Shallow pockets = very heavy flap penalty Also, make the assumption that inexperienced providers arn't going to be able to pay for light flap penalties. So their only choice is to be stable or die. I havn't thought about how or where such a policy would be applied, but the underlying idea would help fix the problem of routing instabilty. I know this one is out there, but I just thought I'd mention it. Scott -- smace(a)neosoft.com - KC5NUA - Scott Mace - Network Engineer - Neosoft Inc. Any opinions expressed are mine.

6 5

AGIS v BBN
by Kent W. England 01 Nov '96

01 Nov '96

Folks; It appears that routes to BBN via AGIS aren't working but others are. Is this true? Perhaps we should start an AGIS Peering Woes List? 1) Digex 2) BBN Planet 3) ?? --Kent

4 3

RE: AGIS v BBN
by Jim Browning 01 Nov '96

01 Nov '96

>From: Kent W. England[SMTP:kwe@6SigmaNets.com] >Sent: Friday, November 01, 1996 9:29 AM > >It appears that routes to BBN via AGIS aren't working but others are. Is >this true? Perhaps we should start an AGIS Peering Woes List? BBN is reachable through AGIS from our network... traceroute to web100.bbnplanet.com (199.94.217.100), 30 hops max, 40 byte packets 1 sd-gw-33-e1.atmnet.net (207.67.247.1) 2 ms 1 ms 2 ms 2 agis-atmnet.losangeles.agis.net (206.62.12.49) 383 ms 40 ms 407 ms 3 a5-0.1009.santaclara3.agis.net (205.254.168.249) 12 ms 14 ms 12 ms 4 mae-w.bbnplanet.net (198.32.136.14) 14 ms 16 ms 14 ms -- Jim Browning

1 0

c|net: Four Horsemen of Net Apocalypse
by Paul Ferguson 01 Nov '96

01 Nov '96

More FUD: http://www.news.com/News/Item/0,4,4975,00.html - paul

1 0

Re: BBN bitten again?
by Andy Sell 01 Nov '96

01 Nov '96

Gentlemen, DNS is configured but there's currently no machine at the IP address. Andy Sell At 12:13 PM 11/1/96 -0500, Deepak Jain wrote: > >I am seeing the same behavior from the East Coast. > >-Deepak. > >On Fri, 1 Nov 1996, Kent W. England wrote: > >> Folks; >> >> Since early yesterday, much or all of BBN Cambridge has been down. >> Anyone know what is going on? More rodent adventures? Or did that gasoline >> truck I fantasized about really turn over into the parking level? >> >> --Kent >> >> >> TraceRoute noc.bbnplanet.com (199.94.209.25) >> timed out >> 1 292 292 205.163.24.49 nb49.cts.com >> 2 278 -14 205.163.24.33 ctshub-e1.cts.com >> 3 332 54 207.67.240.113 cts-gw-ds3.atmnet.net >> 4 306 -26 206.62.12.49 agis-atmnet.losangeles.agis.net >> 5 293 -13 205.254.168.249 a5-0.1009.santaclara3.agis.net >> 6 288 -5 198.32.136.14 mae-w.bbnplanet.net >> 7 277 -11 4.0.20.17 sanjose1-br2.bbnplanet.net >> 8 295 18 4.0.1.81 sanjose1-br1.bbnplanet.net >> 9 309 14 4.0.1.73 oakland-br2.bbnplanet.net >> 10 319 10 4.0.1.134 denver-br1.bbnplanet.net >> 11 313 -6 4.0.1.134 denver-br1.bbnplanet.net >> 12 323 10 4.0.1.190 denver-br2.bbnplanet.net >> 13 336 13 4.0.1.130 chicago1-br1.bbnplanet.net >> 14 407 71 4.0.1.194 chicago1-br2.bbnplanet.net >> 15 381 -26 4.0.1.126 boston1-br1.bbnplanet.net >> 16 613 232 4.0.1.182 boston1-br2.bbnplanet.net >> 17 1752 1139 4.0.1.158 cambridge1-br2.bbnplanet.net >> 18 * * timed out >> 19 * * timed out >> 20 * * timed out >> 21 * * timed out >> 22 * * timed out >> 23 * * timed out >> 24 * * timed out >> 25 * * timed out >> 26 * * timed out >> 27 * * timed out >> 28 * * timed out >> 29 * * timed out >> 30 * * timed out >> not reached >> >> >

1 0