Re: Couple of questions about "baremetal/ONIE" networking equipment sellers
Hi Mike/Drew, We also have lots of experience with FS.com switches; however.. One thing we noticed really quick is that its better to order 1 and to find the actual supplier and order with them directly. FS.com is a reseller; and they will switch (no pun intended) supplier almost yearly. Real technical support is nonexistent (even though they claim it is great) and I have yet to have a single bug fixed; packet dumps and steps to reproduce included. I have removed all of our *N*5850-48S6Q due to bugs in software lockups. Their current *S*5850-48S6Q is developed by Centec Neworks ( http://www.centecnetworks.com/en/SolutionList.asp?ID=91 ) and is the E580-48X6Q (compare the changelog and manual; you will see its a "replace all" job). These switches do actually support LDP/MPLS/VPLS if you buy the license and run them in their 'ipran' profile. Feel free to contact me off list if you have any questions. Kind regards, Nick ten Cate
Date: Fri, 25 Oct 2019 09:25:24 -0700 From: Mike <mike-nanog@tiedyenetworks.com> To: nanog@nanog.org Subject: Re: Couple of questions about "baremetal/ONIE" networking equipment sellers Message-ID: <1f380ffc-ae44-3346-5db3-bf38d290a326@tiedyenetworks.com> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="windows-1252"
On 10/25/19 9:13 AM, Drew Weaver wrote:
Hello,
1. I was reading about Cumulus and came across a note about bm-switch.com, does anyone have any experience purchasing switches from bm-switch.com? What was your experience like? 2. Same question about hardware from FS.com any problems there?
Thanks!
-Drew
I have some experience with FS.com - I have the S5850-48S6Q (https://www.fs.com/products/29123.html) and it does the job. Advanced features like MPLS and such are not available, but for the money I'm quite happy.
* Nick ten Cate
We also have lots of experience with FS.com switches; however.. One thing we noticed really quick is that its better to order 1 and to find the actual supplier and order with them directly. FS.com is a reseller; and they will switch (no pun intended) supplier almost yearly. Real technical support is nonexistent (even though they claim it is great) and I have yet to have a single bug fixed; packet dumps and steps to reproduce included. I have removed all of our *N*5850-48S6Q due to bugs in software lockups.
Hi Nick, FS.com did indeed replace their N5850-58S6Q supplier a while back. It is rather idiotic of them to not change their SKU when they do so. Anyway, before it was manufactured by Celestica I think, now it is the Edge-Core AS5812-54X. The latter is very well supported by Cumulus, the former is not. You can see it is the the Edge-Core by comparing the pictures: https://www.fs.com/de-en/products/69226.html https://www.edge-core.com/productsInfo.php?cls=1&cls2=8&cls3=59&id=119 We bought a few of them. I did mail our AM before placing the order to ascertain that they would indeed deliver the AS5812-54X and to make it crystal clear that no other model would be accepted. No problem. They will also sell other Edge-Core models that's not (yet) on their website catalogue if you ask (we ordered a few AS7326-56Xes). I do not believe Edge-Core will sell direct to end-users, so resellers like FS, Cumulus Networks or HPE is your best bet if you want those. Tore
participants (2)
-
Nick ten Cate
-
Tore Anderson