Very interesting Randy, this sounds like what we endure on a regular basis in the eastern Caribbean....I too would like to know why myself since I have always wondered whether our local networks are set up. Rudi Daniel
From: Randy Bush <randy@psg.com> Subject: very strange internet behavior To: customersupport@caribcable.com Date: Sun, 19 Sep 2010 04:14:08 -0400
[ this needs to be escalated to an internet engineer ]
hi,
i am an old senior internet geek vacationing on nevis's nesbit beach. the cottage has your tv and internet service.
during what i suspect are the busy hours of the day, your internet service borders on useless. it is as if an overloaded NAT is in the middle. one can reach very few web sites. one can reach (ping, ssh, ...) some hosts and not others. and the hosts are in the same rack and same ip address space in a stateside colo. one can ping a host but not ssh to it. or i can be sshed into a host and yet not be able to ping it. very twisty stuff.
if i turn on the tv, the cable seems to be working.
i can run an openvpn tunnel to a stateside or japan-based host and then everything is reachable. of course i have to try three or four of my openvpn serving hosts before i find one which is reachable. this is not a great solution, and certainly not one available to the vast majority of your customers.
from an engineer's point of view, i would love to understand what the cause of all this really is.
randy
------------------------------
_______________________________________________ NANOG mailing list NANOG@nanog.org https://mailman.nanog.org/mailman/listinfo/nanog
End of NANOG Digest, Vol 32, Issue 62 *************************************
-- Rudi Daniel *danielcharles <http://goog_470770575>* consulting <http://goog_470770575>*ICT4Dev & e Business and services<http://goog_470770575> * <http://goog_470770575>*1-784 498 8277 <http://goog_470770575>* ** <http://goog_470770575>*h <http://csisvg.ning.com>ttp://csisvg.ning.com *
Very interesting Randy, this sounds like what we endure on a regular basis in the eastern Caribbean....I too would like to know why myself since I have always wondered whether our local networks are set up.
well, here is the netalyzer report from caribbean cable on north nevis at a good time http://netalyzr.icsi.berkeley.edu/restore/id=43ca253f-6723-1110f506-4d39-465... of course, this is a rough state of the art measurement of services and performance. but i am not aware of a tool that will help diagnose connectivity issues such as i am seeing, see OP. anyone with clue on that please holler. it smells to me as if there is a middle-box or three which think they are too smart and just do not scale. but i really have no idea. randy
participants (2)
-
Randy Bush
-
Rudolph Daniel