Re: GigaRouter (Was Re: Cisco as Big Brother))
Michael Dillon writes:
You can also try building a machine with a boot device like the 2.88 megabyte floppies. Using the same techniques FreeBSD uses for their boot disks, you can decompress the boot floppy into a large RAMDISK and run that way. Or simply use a ZIP drive for the boot device but run from RAM as before. It's not as good as 100% solid state but it comes pretty close.
This isn't clear to me. Why do you assume a ZIP is likely to be more reliable that a hard disk? ZIPs haven't been around long enough to be sure of this, and HDs are pretty reliable these days.
Of course I'm not saying that I *Want* to use an HD in this situation; flash is clearly a big win. But I don't see how using a floppy or ZIP improves wins.
FWIW, I suspect that building a 1.4MB fs that can boot and then nfs-mount (or ftp to a memory fs) needed binaries would be not a lot harder for FreeBSD or BSDi than it was for NetBSD.
Not really, the BSDI installation procedure does it with one floppy. The BSDI bootstrap knows how to load a gzipped kernel image. I've made modified boot disks from their installation procedure. I've never turned on NFS though, and admittedly it's all packed in there tight enough that every time I want to do something else I'm deleting one thing to add another. An 8mb flash card for $300 would be very nice if it worked. Rob
On Sat, 19 Oct 96 15:24:10 PDT Rob Liebschutz <rob@rjl.com> alleged:
Not really, the BSDI installation procedure does it with one floppy. The BSDI bootstrap knows how to load a gzipped kernel image. I've made modified boot disks from their installation procedure. I've never turned on NFS though, and admittedly it's all packed in there tight enough that every time I want to do something else I'm deleting one thing to add another. An 8mb flash card for $300 would be very nice if it worked.
Well if you're talking i386. For NetBSD/i386 work is being done to make gzip'ed kernels boot at thi time. Regards, Neil. -- Neil J. McRae. Alive and Kicking. E A S Y N E T G R O U P P L C neil@EASYNET.NET NetBSD/sparc: 100% SpF (Solaris protection Factor) Free the daemon in your <A HREF="http://www.NetBSD.ORG/">computer!</A> [N.B.: I have no affilation with Cyberia or the CyberWorkers Unite Party]
participants (2)
-
Neil J. McRae
-
Rob Liebschutz