Re: Why aren't ISPs providing stratum 1 NTP service?
So the list works... if you don't want to provide "public" services, adjust the server to allow connections only from your own IP blocks.
Currently I, and the company I work for, don't mind providing some services to the "public" Internet community. The company almost always gets more out of it than it costs to supply. I just don't want to get trapped into "supporting" public services. I get enough hate mail now when one of our no charge services goes out of service on occasion. A related, but more on topic for NANOG, issue is aligning more network services with network topology. I don't think putting a NTP stratum 1 server on the NAP network fabric is a good idea. I do think providers exchanging NTP across the NAP fabric is a good idea. Redundant voting catches a bunch of dumb errors. A packet saved, is a packet you don't have to carry. Its not as huge a problem as multiple MBONE tunnels transiting the same physical lines. But I'd rather have multiple associations at the edge of my network, and pass NTP in a structured manner around inside my network. The same thing is true for several other network services. -- Sean Donelan, Data Research Associates, Inc, St. Louis, MO Affiliation given for identification not representation
On Fri, 19 Jul 1996, Sean Donelan wrote:
A related, but more on topic for NANOG, issue is aligning more network services with network topology.
I've always felt that the topology of USENET news distribution could be done better if it matched the topology better. I'm not sure how best to do this although a decent set of maps of the USENET topology might be enough to make news admins adjust things on their own. And heavily used WWW servers are another thing that could benefit from aligning themselves with the topology. I'm thinking of a scenario where the service was actually provided by a distributed set of WWW servers located one hop from an XP, maybe at an XP peer's special customer colo site, and the central WW server site would issue redirects to the topologically closest WWW server. For this to work best I think network operators would need to provide some data to allow the customer to more effectively redistribute their traffic load. Michael Dillon - ISP & Internet Consulting Memra Software Inc. - Fax: +1-604-546-3049 http://www.memra.com - E-mail: michael@memra.com
participants (2)
-
Michael Dillon
-
Sean Donelan