I'm attempting to convince "the powers that be" that attempting to use reverse lookups to determine geographic locale is extremely inaccurate. One of the reasons among the many this is the case (I believe) is that significant portion of admins do not have properly configured in-addr. Has anyone done this sort of survey(Bill Manning?) If so, anyone have a pointer handy? Thanks.
I'd have to say that the people you'll be blocking doing this will be legitemately blocked. Now the problem comes from the ppl who don't have reverse DNS setup properly. Lets say you'd like to block download of a crypto software to everybody in Yugoslavia, by not allowing downloads from everybody comming from .yu, your legimately blocking a bunch of people, but then, everybody comming from a .com in yugoslavia are going straight through. And you still don't have control over someone that'll decide to dial-up all the way to another country to download your crypto software. On Fri, 11 May 2001, Patrick Greenwell wrote:
I'm attempting to convince "the powers that be" that attempting to use reverse lookups to determine geographic locale is extremely inaccurate. One of the reasons among the many this is the case (I believe) is that significant portion of admins do not have properly configured in-addr. Has anyone done this sort of survey(Bill Manning?) If so, anyone have a pointer handy?
Thanks.
-- -S SysAdmin sberube@zks.net Interviewer: "So Frank, you have long hair. Does that make you a woman?" FZ: "You have a wooden leg. Does that make you a table?"
I'm attempting to convince "the powers that be" that attempting to use reverse lookups to determine geographic locale is extremely inaccurate. One of the reasons among the many this is the case (I believe) is that significant portion of admins do not have properly configured in-addr. Has anyone done this sort of survey(Bill Manning?) If so, anyone have a pointer handy?
Thanks.
Define "proper" please. Depending on what the selection criteria are and where one is looking, the numbers vary. The Mice&Men numbers indicate upwords of 75% of the delegations are flawed. My numbers point to about 55-60% of the delegations have some errors. On a bad day, I'm surprised the thing works as well as it does. -bill
participants (3)
-
bmanning@vacation.karoshi.com
-
Patrick Greenwell
-
Sebastien Berube