Integrated WIFI router and phone adapter
Hi NANOG Community Anyone knows about a good integrated WIFI router and phone adapter that can be used to provide home and business internet and phone service. We tried couple of them but we've seen some instability and reliability issues (i.e. wifi issues, phone issues, etc.). Also some of them are designed to work better over DSL but not over DOCSIS. Thank you KARIM M.
On 18/May/20 07:00, K MEKKAOUI wrote:
Hi NANOG Community
Anyone knows about a good integrated WIFI router and phone adapter that can be used to provide home and business internet and phone service. We tried couple of them but we’ve seen some instability and reliability issues (i.e. wifi issues, phone issues, etc.). Also some of them are designed to work better over DSL but not over DOCSIS.
Have you looked at Calix: https://www.calix.com/platforms/non-exos-premises-systems/gigafamily-overvie... You don't mention what last mile you're using. The Calix Giga units are for GPON. Mark.
+1 But yes -- GPON. On 5/18/20 9:03 AM, Mark Tinka wrote:
On 18/May/20 07:00, K MEKKAOUI wrote:
Hi NANOG Community
Anyone knows about a good integrated WIFI router and phone adapter that can be used to provide home and business internet and phone service. We tried couple of them but we’ve seen some instability and reliability issues (i.e. wifi issues, phone issues, etc.). Also some of them are designed to work better over DSL but not over DOCSIS.
Have you looked at Calix:
https://www.calix.com/platforms/non-exos-premises-systems/gigafamily-overvie...
You don't mention what last mile you're using. The Calix Giga units are for GPON.
Mark.
They have an Ethernet version and GPON version. The GPON version is the same price their Ethernet version + low end GPON ONT. We stayed away from the GPON version for WiFi reasons. Want the techs thinking about a good RF location. Don't want them thinking about easy/good fiber routing. Kevin Burke 802-540-0979 Burlington Telecom 200 Church St, Burlington, VT On 5/18/20, 9:46 AM, "NANOG on behalf of Bryan Holloway" <nanog-bounces@nanog.org on behalf of bryan@shout.net> wrote: WARNING!! This message originated from an External Source. Please use proper judgment and caution when opening attachments, clicking links, or responding to this email. +1 But yes -- GPON. On 5/18/20 9:03 AM, Mark Tinka wrote: > > > On 18/May/20 07:00, K MEKKAOUI wrote: >> >> Hi NANOG Community >> >> Anyone knows about a good integrated WIFI router and phone adapter >> that can be used to provide home and business internet and phone >> service. We tried couple of them but we’ve seen some instability and >> reliability issues (i.e. wifi issues, phone issues, etc.). Also some >> of them are designed to work better over DSL but not over DOCSIS. >> > > Have you looked at Calix: > > https://www.calix.com/platforms/non-exos-premises-systems/gigafamily-overvie... > > You don't mention what last mile you're using. The Calix Giga units are > for GPON. > > Mark.
On 18/May/20 16:45, Kevin Burke wrote:
They have an Ethernet version and GPON version.
The GPON version is the same price their Ethernet version + low end GPON ONT.
We stayed away from the GPON version for WiFi reasons. Want the techs thinking about a good RF location. Don't want them thinking about easy/good fiber routing.
To drive POTS lines, I suppose they are fine. But agree that for home wi-fi, you're better off having a dedicated AP so that you don't compromise wi-fi quality due to the fibre loop coming into the back of your office/house, where only dust lives :-). Mark.
don't forget to disable SIP-ALG on the units. That will be a huge improvement. On 5/18/20 12:34 PM, Mark Tinka wrote:
On 18/May/20 16:45, Kevin Burke wrote:
They have an Ethernet version and GPON version.
The GPON version is the same price their Ethernet version + low end GPON ONT.
We stayed away from the GPON version for WiFi reasons. Want the techs thinking about a good RF location. Don't want them thinking about easy/good fiber routing. To drive POTS lines, I suppose they are fine.
But agree that for home wi-fi, you're better off having a dedicated AP so that you don't compromise wi-fi quality due to the fibre loop coming into the back of your office/house, where only dust lives :-).
Mark.
On 5/18/20 1:00 AM, K MEKKAOUI wrote:
Anyone knows about a good integrated WIFI router and phone adapter that can be used to provide home and business internet and phone service. We tried couple of them but we’ve seen some instability and reliability issues (i.e. wifi issues, phone issues, etc.). Also some of them are designed to work better over DSL but not over DOCSIS.
SmartRG (now part of Adtran) has some Ethernet-connected and therefore largely provider-tech agnostic models with FXS ports. I've not used the voice functionality of them, but I've been quite happy with the Wi-Fi and NAT, and they generally "do the right thing" out of the box for most folks. -- Brandon Martin
participants (6)
-
Brandon Martin -
Bryan Holloway -
Curtis Maurand -
K MEKKAOUI -
Kevin Burke -
Mark Tinka