If you're on cogent, since 22:30 UTC yesterday or so this has been happening (or happened). *> 186.177.184.0/23 38.*.*.* 45050 0 174 262206 262206 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 ? oddly, i see other pops with 174 sources giving a more sane route (even 6939 is giving us a route that goes thru 174 after 2 hops). 'Sup, 174? Wonder if this is just stuck in the router Im looking at and the update process is failing because the route is too long to process properly for removal or something. mmm, bugs!) /kc -- Ken Chase - math@sizone.org Guelph Canada
If you're on cogent, since 22:30 UTC yesterday or so this has been happening (or happened).
Still happening here. I count 562 prepends (563 * 262197) in the advertisement we receive from Cogent. I see no good reason why we should accept that many prepends. Steinar Haug, Nethelp consulting, sthaug@nethelp.no
Maybe the next best path had, had 562 prepends? :) On Sat, Sep 30, 2017 at 12:09 PM, <sthaug@nethelp.no> wrote:
If you're on cogent, since 22:30 UTC yesterday or so this has been happening (or happened).
Still happening here. I count 562 prepends (563 * 262197) in the advertisement we receive from Cogent. I see no good reason why we should accept that many prepends.
Steinar Haug, Nethelp consulting, sthaug@nethelp.no
Its also happily announced onwards, e.g. by Telia: Oct 2 07:25:09:E:BGP: From Peer ... received Long AS_PATH= AS_SEQ(2) 1299 174 262206 262206 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 ... attribute length (567) More than configured MAXAS-LIMIT 64 On 30 Sep 2017, at 17:09, sthaug@nethelp.no wrote:
If you're on cogent, since 22:30 UTC yesterday or so this has been happening (or happened).
Still happening here. I count 562 prepends (563 * 262197) in the advertisement we receive from Cogent. I see no good reason why we should accept that many prepends.
Steinar Haug, Nethelp consulting, sthaug@nethelp.no
Got this reply from cogent: "We have isolated a BGP Routing discrepancy on the Backbone. That routing has been removed from the Network." So apparently they agree they shouldn't just accept this bogosity. Good on em. /kc -- Ken Chase - math@sizone.org Guelph Canada
<TheGiant> It is happening AGAIN. And of course it started on a friday aft 15 min before quittin' time in EDT: Last time it was 186.177.184.0/23 0 174 262206 262206 262197 262197 *> 186.176.186.0/23 38.x.x.x 45050 0 174 262206 262206 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 ? /kc -- Ken Chase - math@sizone.org Guelph Canada
Has anyone tried calling them? Kind regards, Job On Fri, 13 Oct 2017 at 23:03, Ken Chase <math@sizone.org> wrote:
<TheGiant> It is happening AGAIN.
And of course it started on a friday aft 15 min before quittin' time in EDT:
Last time it was 186.177.184.0/23 0 174 262206 262206 262197 262197
*> 186.176.186.0/23 38.x.x.x 45050 0 174 262206 262206 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 ?
/kc -- Ken Chase - math@sizone.org Guelph Canada
And again this morn at 08:35:19 EST (13:35 UTC). I dont have access to the router that fed us the long route, so I cant tell what it was (since we never consumed it before barfing). Let's hope for no more over holiday season... /kc On Fri, Oct 13, 2017 at 05:02:42PM -0400, Ken Chase said:
<TheGiant> It is happening AGAIN.
And of course it started on a friday aft 15 min before quittin' time in EDT:
Last time it was 186.177.184.0/23 0 174 262206 262206 262197 262197
*> 186.176.186.0/23 38.x.x.x 45050 0 174 262206 262206 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 ?
/kc -- Ken Chase - math@sizone.org Guelph Canada
-- Ken Chase - math@sizone.org Guelph Canada
What router software version are you running that barfs on long as-paths? Nick Ken Chase wrote:
And again this morn at 08:35:19 EST (13:35 UTC). I dont have access to the router that fed us the long route, so I cant tell what it was (since we never consumed it before barfing).
Let's hope for no more over holiday season...
/kc
On Fri, Oct 13, 2017 at 05:02:42PM -0400, Ken Chase said:
<TheGiant> It is happening AGAIN.
And of course it started on a friday aft 15 min before quittin' time in EDT:
Last time it was 186.177.184.0/23 0 174 262206 262206 262197 262197
*> 186.176.186.0/23 38.x.x.x 45050 0 174 262206 262206 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262 197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 26 2197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 ?
/kc -- Ken Chase - math@sizone.org Guelph Canada
quagga 0.99.22.4, yes i need to upgrade, as my other router on 0.99.23.1 seems ok. now coordinating with customers to get it upgraded is a different issue. /kc On Fri, Dec 22, 2017 at 05:40:28PM +0000, Nick Hilliard said:
What router software version are you running that barfs on long as-paths?
Nick
Ken Chase wrote:
And again this morn at 08:35:19 EST (13:35 UTC). I dont have access to the router that fed us the long route, so I cant tell what it was (since we never consumed it before barfing).
Let's hope for no more over holiday season...
/kc
On Fri, Oct 13, 2017 at 05:02:42PM -0400, Ken Chase said:
<TheGiant> It is happening AGAIN.
And of course it started on a friday aft 15 min before quittin' time in EDT:
Last time it was 186.177.184.0/23 0 174 262206 262206 262197 262197
*> 186.176.186.0/23 38.x.x.x 45050 0 174 262206 262206 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262 197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 26 2197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 ?
/kc -- Ken Chase - math@sizone.org Guelph Canada
On 12/22/2017 12:46 PM, Ken Chase wrote:
quagga 0.99.22.4, yes i need to upgrade, as my other router on 0.99.23.1 seems ok. now coordinating with customers to get it upgraded is a different issue.
Will that version of quagga not support a filter list? e.g neighbor 38.xx.yy.zz filter-list maxas-limit65 in ip as-path access-list maxas-limit65 deny ^([{},0-9]+ ){65} ip as-path access-list maxas-limit65 permit .* ---Mike
/kc
On Fri, Dec 22, 2017 at 05:40:28PM +0000, Nick Hilliard said:
What router software version are you running that barfs on long as-paths?
Nick
Ken Chase wrote:
And again this morn at 08:35:19 EST (13:35 UTC). I dont have access to the router that fed us the long route, so I cant tell what it was (since we never consumed it before barfing).
Let's hope for no more over holiday season...
/kc
On Fri, Oct 13, 2017 at 05:02:42PM -0400, Ken Chase said:
<TheGiant> It is happening AGAIN.
And of course it started on a friday aft 15 min before quittin' time in EDT:
Last time it was 186.177.184.0/23 0 174 262206 262206 262197 262197
*> 186.176.186.0/23 38.x.x.x 45050 0 174 262206 262206 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262 197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 26 2197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 262197 ?
/kc -- Ken Chase - math@sizone.org Guelph Canada
-- ------------------- Mike Tancsa, tel +1 519 651 3400 Sentex Communications, mike@sentex.net Providing Internet services since 1994 www.sentex.net Cambridge, Ontario Canada http://www.tancsa.com/
On Fri, Dec 22, 2017 at 12:40 PM, Nick Hilliard <nick@foobar.org> wrote:
What router software version are you running that barfs on long as-paths?
Hi Nick, Versions of quagga up until the very most recent release corrupt the transmission of routes with very long AS paths. They add up the packet length wrong. The neighbors of any router brand then barf on the malformed data and terminate the BGP session. Your peer running quagga must either upgrade or filter long AS paths or you will receive corrupt data and terminate the BGP session. There's nothing that -you- can do about it. The AS path lengths we're talking about are unreasonable. They indicate a high probability of misconfiguration at the origin. There's no legitimate cause for them to exist on the pubic Internet at all. It would be reasonable to treat them like when peers offer /32 prefixes and just say no. Regards, Bill Herrin -- William Herrin ................ herrin@dirtside.com bill@herrin.us Dirtside Systems ......... Web: <http://www.dirtside.com/>
William Herrin wrote:
The AS path lengths we're talking about are unreasonable.
"unreasonable" is a peculiar word to use here :-) It's the internet and you can't expect other people not to do silly things from time to time. This is a known problem and it isn't even the first time it's been discussed on nanog-l. If you've been hit with a known service-affecting problem that can easily recur without warning and which will be service affecting if it hits again, common sense suggests that it would be a good idea to upgrade to a version of code which isn't affected. Nick
On Fri, Dec 22, 2017 at 5:45 PM, Nick Hilliard <nick@foobar.org> wrote:
William Herrin wrote:
The AS path lengths we're talking about are unreasonable.
"unreasonable" is a peculiar word to use here :-)
It's the internet and you can't expect other people not to do silly things from time to time. This is a known problem and it isn't even the first time it's been discussed on nanog-l.
If you've been hit with a known service-affecting problem that can easily recur without warning and which will be service affecting if it hits again, common sense suggests that it would be a good idea to upgrade to a version of code which isn't affected.
Well, that's a brilliant platitude, but what do you do when it breaks over and over until the other guy upgrades? -Bill -- William Herrin ................ herrin@dirtside.com bill@herrin.us Dirtside Systems ......... Web: <http://www.dirtside.com/>
Push harder on upgrading. "Dec 30" is my earliest window I got from my customer after previously pushing with previous events (didnt help that Cogent said "yeah we agree these are silly, we'll be filtering more aggressively" -- this time it snuck in from the less busy side of our network). It's not even going to be service impacting, if we do everything correctly, but *who knows for sure* :) Course more long path events occurring ARE service impacting more than the risk during upgrade, so go figure. Customers! Cant live with em, cant afford to live without em! Nonetheless, I do think that backbones should be filtering ridiculous AS paths just as a matter of course. Everyone fix their own stuff, and everyone help the next guy downstream by stomping on sillyness. Generally been an internet mindset that I've seen since even before the great renaming... /kc On Fri, Dec 22, 2017 at 05:50:36PM -0500, William Herrin said:
On Fri, Dec 22, 2017 at 5:45 PM, Nick Hilliard <nick@foobar.org> wrote:
William Herrin wrote:
The AS path lengths we're talking about are unreasonable.
"unreasonable" is a peculiar word to use here :-)
It's the internet and you can't expect other people not to do silly things from time to time. This is a known problem and it isn't even the first time it's been discussed on nanog-l.
If you've been hit with a known service-affecting problem that can easily recur without warning and which will be service affecting if it hits again, common sense suggests that it would be a good idea to upgrade to a version of code which isn't affected.
Well, that's a brilliant platitude, but what do you do when it breaks over and over until the other guy upgrades?
-Bill
-- William Herrin ................ herrin@dirtside.com bill@herrin.us Dirtside Systems ......... Web: <http://www.dirtside.com/>
/kc -- Ken Chase - math@sizone.org Guelph Canada
William Herrin wrote:
On Fri, Dec 22, 2017 at 5:45 PM, Nick Hilliard <nick@foobar.org> wrote: If you've been hit with a known service-affecting problem that can easily recur without warning and which will be service affecting if it hits again, common sense suggests that it would be a good idea to upgrade to a version of code which isn't affected.
Well, that's a brilliant platitude, but what do you do when it breaks over and over until the other guy upgrades?
I dunno, maybe shake our fists and rage a bit about the existence of service affecting bugs? It's not like we haven't all been in this position at one stage or another. The point was, though, that there's been several months since this bug was discussed on nanog-l way back in balmy september, and given the fact that it can completely wipe out connectivity without warning for those affected, it would have been a good idea to deal with the problem in an orderly way at the time rather than letting it interfere with eggnog and seasonal good cheer, at one of the times of year where chunks of the world are busy taking well-deserved holidays. On which point, seasonal cheers to all. Nick
Ive found some other stuff that's totally busted, but screw those who havent patched their systems. We should not help them at all as knowlegeable stewards of big chunks of bandwidth, we should just write stuff about how silly they are instead: https://www.usenix.org/system/files/conference/woot14/woot14-kuhrer.pdf read the first table on page 3 and then explain the philosophy of not caring about this as a general issue affecting the entire internet. That's not, to date, been the attitude I've seen in here or elsewhere amongst admins, and I dont see why we should start now. (And I'd fix it _right now_, but it's at my major customer's discretion. I've explained the risks, he's taken them to heart. He too is an actual seasoned admin (with quagga experience), but turned off his AS least year and got out of the game. He has his reasons for waiting a bit longer.) /kc On Fri, Dec 22, 2017 at 11:11:44PM +0000, Nick Hilliard said:
William Herrin wrote:
On Fri, Dec 22, 2017 at 5:45 PM, Nick Hilliard <nick@foobar.org> wrote: If you've been hit with a known service-affecting problem that can easily recur without warning and which will be service affecting if it hits again, common sense suggests that it would be a good idea to upgrade to a version of code which isn't affected.
Well, that's a brilliant platitude, but what do you do when it breaks over and over until the other guy upgrades?
I dunno, maybe shake our fists and rage a bit about the existence of service affecting bugs? It's not like we haven't all been in this position at one stage or another.
The point was, though, that there's been several months since this bug was discussed on nanog-l way back in balmy september, and given the fact that it can completely wipe out connectivity without warning for those affected, it would have been a good idea to deal with the problem in an orderly way at the time rather than letting it interfere with eggnog and seasonal good cheer, at one of the times of year where chunks of the world are busy taking well-deserved holidays.
On which point, seasonal cheers to all.
Nick
-- Ken Chase - ken@heavycomputing.ca skype:kenchase23 +1 416 897 6284 Toronto Canada Heavy Computing - Clued bandwidth, colocation and managed linux VPS @151 Front St. W.
Ken Chase wrote:
(And I'd fix it _right now_, but it's at my major customer's discretion.
ok, so this is a customer management problem. If this is the only customer on that router, then ok, if they want to continue putting themselves at risk of service loss, I guess that would be their concern. If there's anyone else connected to this router, then you would probably want to consider moving them off it, because you seem to have said that you may not have full control of your business assets. If this is the case, it isn't a good situation to be in and will lead to issues like this turning into serious longer term problems.
read the first table on page 3 and then explain the philosophy of not caring about this as a general issue affecting the entire internet. That's not, to date, been the attitude I've seen in here or elsewhere amongst admins, and I dont see why we should start now.
Globally, there are 59000 ASNs announcing a total of 670k ipv4 prefixes and 45k ipv6 routes. If any one of those prefixes is announced anywhere in the world with an oddball as-path, then this puts vulnerable versions of quagga at risk of service loss. This isn't about sympathy or caring or not caring or anything else, but the uncomfortable fact that with a pool this large, mistakes are going to happen from time to time, whether we like it or not. It's as-path length this time, but on previous occasions it's been attribute size, or incorrect attribute combos or, well, a small catalog of other problems that have caused bgp session failure globally over the years. It's each of our responsibility to ensure that our systems are resistant to problems like this, not other peoples' responsibility to ensure that our networks don't get hit by third party misconfigs. Nick
Den 23. dec. 2017 01.02 skrev "Nick Hilliard" <nick@foobar.org>: This isn't about sympathy or caring or not caring or anything else, but the uncomfortable fact that with a pool this large, mistakes are going to happen from time to time, whether we like it or not. It is not even a mistake but just some uninformed guy thinking I really want this to be a path of last resort, so I will write a real large number in this field.
participants (9)
-
Baldur Norddahl
-
jim deleskie
-
Job Snijders
-
Jörg Kost
-
Ken Chase
-
Mike Tancsa
-
Nick Hilliard
-
sthaug@nethelp.no
-
William Herrin