Classfull registration in RAdb.

I am currently registering routes for the company I work for and I am wondering whether I should register customers classfull space. In getting a list of our route assignments by comparing global BGP table route origins with ARIN SWIP information, I came across a number of class-B's that belong to customers that are not doing BGP with us. All the blocks are portable space, and I am wondering whether it would be correct to create route objects with our ASN as the "origin:" or to require them to register their space and use our ASN in the "origin:" attribute of the route object. Though I understand responsibility for route registration lies with the maintainer of the block, if they choose not to create a maintainer object, other sites will not get the customers routes from the RAdb if they are generating access-lists using our policy object. If the address space is portable, but they do not have an ASN, who has the authority to regsiter the route object to a particular ASN? Thanks to Gerald Andrew Winters from Merit for his previous assistance in helping me with the policy here. I just thought that I'd bring these issues up in a public forum as they don't seem to be documented. -j -- jamie.reid | Spare Parts for the Human Appliance Chief Reverse Engineer | www.vapour.net Defective Technologies |

I am currently registering routes for the company I work for and I am wondering whether I should register customers classfull space.
I think that you should; if you are the origin AS, and people can't find a route object for a route that you inject with yourself as the origin AS, the question of why the route object hasn't been created is more likely to go to you than to the owner of the address space. Additionally, you have all the data necessary to do a complete job. If you delegate the task to your customers, some will do it, some won't.
If the address space is portable, but they do not have an ASN, who has the authority to regsiter the route object to a particular ASN?
The owner of the ASN used as the origin AS should have the authority to create route objects to document previously-undocumented address space, in the interest of a better/accurate RAdb. Stephen
participants (2)
-
batz
-
Stephen Stuart