Re: Optical Crossconnects and IP
I would like to inject some sanity into the traffic engineering discussion by reminding about some small fact of life: Nobody knows how to measure how what the demanded/available bandwidth ratio is when the circuit is overloaded. In a steady more, utilization is s 100%; packet loss is not an accurate gauge, by any means (it depends on delays, agressiveness os sources, queue manageent policies, timing of source starts, and phase of the moon). What it means that by and large traffic engineering is done by seat of the pants. An attempt to create a close control loop with that kind of source information is somewhat problematic. And so is "wavelength on demand". When circuits aren't overloaded, traffic engineering yields zero benefit. --vadim PS I just love engineers spending untold hours and companies spending billions on a technology of questionable worth and little theoretical foundations, instead of spending a small fraction of it on research first. PPS Pluris core technology allows to treat traffic as a liquid - unlike simple IP routing it works by splitting aggregated streams, which can be sent along different paths. It makes any VC-based traffic engineering and associated hardware overhead simply unnecessary. I'm more than a little disappointed by the fact that this is apparently lost in the mind of the company's current architects. (Admittedly, it still requires some work on algorithms, but at least routing of colored liquids is much easier computationally than routing of VCs).
When circuits aren't overloaded, traffic engineering yields zero benefit.
Slightly disingenuous - Yes, TE yields zero benefit in terms of getting more 'efficient' use of bandwidth resource (if you have bandwidth that's idle when the network is used inefficiently, who cares) and in terms of traffic prioritization (if it all gets through without queuing delay, who cares). But the apostles of TE claim more miracles than the above two for their religion (all the funky stuff from encapsulation for instance). Now whether one doubts these miracles too is another matter... -- Alex Bligh VP Core Network, Concentric Network Corporation (formerly GX Networks, Xara Networks)
| I would like to inject some sanity into the traffic engineering | discussion by reminding about some small fact of life: | | Nobody knows how to measure how what the demanded/available bandwidth | ratio is when the circuit is overloaded. This was never a requirement. The requirement is to move traffic off the overloaded circuit. Tony
participants (3)
-
Alex Bligh
-
Tony Li
-
Vadim Antonov