Re: Draft internic ip allocation doc
All ISPs receiving /16 prefix blocks from the InterNIC will be responsible for maintaining all IN-ADDR.ARPA domain records for their respective customers. The InterNIC Registry will only be responsible for the maintenance of IN-ADDR.ARPA domain records for those CIDR blocks with prefixes longer than /16 issued directly from the InterNIC. I think you mean shorter, as in: The InterNIC Registry will only be responsible for the maintenance of IN-ADDR.ARPA domain records for those CIDR blocks with prefixes SHORTER than /16 issued directly from the InterNIC. No, I think he means longer. IN-ADDR.ARPA can only be delegated on octet boundaries, so IN-ADDR for /16 and shorter prefixes will be delegated in /16 chunks. IN-ADDR for prefixes longer than /16 must still be maintained by the root, since they cannot be delegated. For example, assume an ISP has been allocated the prefix 204.160/14. Along with this, the InterNIC will delegate the corresponding IN-ADDR domains: 160.204.IN-ADDR.ARPA 161.204.IN-ADDR.ARPA 162.204.IN-ADDR.ARPA 163.204.IN-ADDR.ARPA If the ISP were instead only assigned 204.160.0/17, the associated IN-ADDR range would be: 0.160.204.IN-ADDR.ARPA ... 127.160.204.IN-ADDR.ARPA which is not octet-aligned and therefore cannot be delegated. --Vince
No, I think he means longer. IN-ADDR.ARPA can only be delegated on octet boundaries, so IN-ADDR for /16 and shorter prefixes will be delegated in /16 chunks. IN-ADDR for prefixes longer than /16 must still be maintained by the root, since they cannot be delegated.
Silly me. I've been working with a tree that does non-octet delegations for a few weeks and it has warpped my thinking. You are correct that in todays world, longer is right. Sorry for the confusion. -- --bill
No, I think he means longer. IN-ADDR.ARPA can only be delegated on octet boundaries, so IN-ADDR for /16 and shorter prefixes will be delegated in /16 chunks. IN-ADDR for prefixes longer than /16 must still be maintained by the root, since they cannot be delegated.
For example, assume an ISP has been allocated the prefix 204.160/14. Along with this, the InterNIC will delegate the corresponding IN-ADDR domains:
160.204.IN-ADDR.ARPA 161.204.IN-ADDR.ARPA 162.204.IN-ADDR.ARPA 163.204.IN-ADDR.ARPA
If the ISP were instead only assigned 204.160.0/17, the associated IN-ADDR range would be:
0.160.204.IN-ADDR.ARPA ... 127.160.204.IN-ADDR.ARPA
which is not octet-aligned and therefore cannot be delegated.
Well, you can delegate these as 128 individual zones. With a little bit of automation to help, it may approach practical. You can delegate a single domain name in the limiting case. Louis A. Mamakos, Manager of Network Engineering louie@uu.net, uunet!louie UUNET Technologies, Inc. Voice: +1 703 206 5823 3060 Williams Drive Fax: +1 703 206 5908 Fairfax, VA 22031
participants (3)
-
bmanning@ISI.EDU
-
Louis A. Mamakos
-
Vince Fuller