In article <cistron.e05f39290511290324l761e676dm2cf141344c966a99@mail.gmail.com>, Kim Onnel <karim.adel@gmail.com> wrote:

We have Juniper ERX as BRAS for ADSL Our humble approach was to collect some p2p ports and police traffic to these ports, but the traffic wasnt much, one other thing is rate-limiting per ADSL customers IPs, but that wasnt supported by management, so we thought of matching ADSL www traffic and doing exceed action is transmit, and police other IP traffic.

Doing so on the ERX wasnt a nice experience, so we're trying to do it on the cisco.

The ERX really has good CoS and QoS controls (not NBAR though AFAIK). It can do it all in hardware, I've heard a lot of good things about it from people who actually use it. If you have a support contract just ask if you can spend a day in a Juniper lab with an engineer to learn how it works (Juniper here in NL definitely does that). Mike.