On Wed, Jul 31, 2019 at 5:29 PM Mark Andrews <marka@isc.org> wrote:
Actually if ARIN doesn’t pull the resources, after notification and a grace period to get them fixed, then what is the point in writing policy requiring that they be up to date and working? There needs to be checks and balances for systems to work. The only
It simplifies complaint language/interaction if there is an actual official RIR policy being violated. If the abuse POC bounces, then you can contact the Admin and Technical WHOIS e-mail addresses to tell them about the issue, and why they should care. "You should care, because your non-functioning abuse is a violation of ARIN Registry Policy." If none of the WHOIS e-mail works, then try calling to report the issue as a last resort. Finally, if none of those go directly to a working contact.... then it seems like the only option left is blacklisting. And seems like the RIRs ought to have a policy where when they confirm this; financial sanctions as in penalty fines would be in order to retain those for whatever organization not taking any of their IP Address Registration and availability of contacts seriously.
thing is what should the grace period be?
-- -Sid