In message <4B92C9F7.4080301@unwiredbb.com>, Shon Elliott writes:
My first reply to this thread. I've been kind of tracking it.
I would love to move to IPv6. However, the IPv6 addressing, I have to say, is really tough to remember and understand for most people. Where is a four numb er dotted quad was easy to remember, an IPv6 address.. not so much. I wished the y had made that a little easier when they were drafting up the protocol specs.
Actually a lot of thought went into how to present 128 bit addresses and the current format is actually easier and more compact than the alternatives.
basically, you need technical knowledge to even understand how the IP address is split up.
Actually IPv6 address are usually easier to split up than IPv4 addresses. You can take the presentation format of a IPv6 address and work out the host and network components without having to bit logic in your head. Take this real address 2001:470:1f00:820:214:22ff:fed9:fbdc. Its expanded form is 2001:0470:1f00:0820:0214:22ff:fed9:fbdc. The network component is 2001:470:1f00:820::/64. The host component it ::214:22ff:fed9:fbdc. If it was from a /56 the site would be 2001:470:1f00:800::/56 and it would be the 0x20 (32) subnet. If it was from a /48 the site would be 2001:470:1f00::/48 and it would be in the 0x820 (2080) subnet. IPv6 addresses are big enough that one can put the break points on nibble boundaries so that it is easy for the end user to work this all out. ISP's may get non-nibble break points but end users, unless the ISP is being stupid, will not see them. Compared with you have 192.223.8.96/27 IPv6 is easy. Bigger but easier which you will find once you actually work with IPv6 addresses.
I wished ARIN would waive the fee for service provider's first bloc k of IPv6 as well. It would help make the dual stack deployment easier.
I know IPv4 is running out. I understand the situation. I just wished they ha d put a little more thought into the user experience side of the addressing. Yo u can all flog me now if you want. I expect it. I'm green on IPv6. I would love the education if I am wrong.
-S -- Mark Andrews, ISC 1 Seymour St., Dundas Valley, NSW 2117, Australia PHONE: +61 2 9871 4742 INTERNET: marka@isc.org