On Wed, 13 Aug 2003, Mans Nilsson wrote:
Subject: Re: Port blocking last resort in fight against virus Date: Wed, Aug 13, 2003 at 09:57:56AM +0100 Quoting Stephen J. Wilcox (steve@telecomplete.co.uk):
Sorry I see where you're coming from on this but firewalls are more than just patches to broken OS's.
In your world DoS traffic would be free to roam the networks as it pleased without being throttled sensibly at ingress?
Providing one makes people responsible for what their boxes (not aggregates of networks) cause, and enforces this, there will be no DoS traffic; given a perfect world.
What if the people running the boxes are irresponsible, perhaps even harboring malicious intent
Even in an imperfect world, the solution lies in the edge, not even the CPE, but the end node, if you want to do more than pathetic bandaiding of the inherent problem of insecure applications on end nodes.
I dont have control of all end nodes but I do control my edge. Steve