Yakov, if you have data that CIDR is -not- working for new allocations please present it here.
Simon,
From the last CIDRD meeting (Erik-Jan Bos's slides), we have strong data which indicates that the routing table sizes are again growing at the double-every-nine-months rate. Thus the obvious concern. The exact source of this growth has not been determined quantitatively.
Tony Which somewhat explains why this group reminds me of a bunch of decapitated hens. Would it be correct to interpret your last sentence as: We don't what the underlying cause of the growth in prefixes is (new allocations, old allocations, ISP's not aggregating). With other words, we don't even know if the I-D in question is fixing the right problem. Simon