On Wed, Mar 06, 2002 at 09:41:55AM -0500, Steven M. Bellovin wrote:
In message <gu9ofi1rcwe.fsf@rampart.argfrp.us.uu.net>, Eric Brandwine writes:
Firewalls are good things for general purpose networks. When you've got a bunch of clueless employees, all using Windows shares, NFS, and all sorts of nasty protocols, a firewall is best practice. Rather than educate every single one of them as to the security implications of their actions, just insulate them, and do what you can behind the firewall.
When you've got a deployed server, run by clueful people, dedicated to a single task, firewalls are not the way to go. You've got a DNS server. What are you going to do with a firewall? Permit tcp/53 and udp/53 from the appropriate net blocks. Where's the protection? Turn off unneeded services, chose a resilient and flame tested daemon, and watch the patchlist for it.
Precisely. You *may* need a packet filter to block things like SNMP (to name a recent case in point), but a general-purpose firewall is generally the wrong solution for appliance computers.
Hmm...but certainly part of the right solution for a general "appliance" network. -ron