Hi Erik, as a follow-up to this email from back in April...previously I hadn't yet tested any qos things on the ACX5048. Now I have tested some policing and seems to be working thus far in the lab. I am policing at the unit (subinterface) level to I can accomplish per-vlan/per-unit policers. I have 5 policers like this.... {master:0} agould@eng-lab-5048-2> show configuration firewall | display set | grep policer set firewall policer test-policer-1000 if-exceeding bandwidth-limit 100k set firewall policer test-policer-1000 if-exceeding burst-size-limit 3125 set firewall policer test-policer-1000 then discard set firewall policer test-policer-1001 if-exceeding bandwidth-limit 100k set firewall policer test-policer-1001 if-exceeding burst-size-limit 3125 set firewall policer test-policer-1001 then discard set firewall policer test-policer-1002 if-exceeding bandwidth-limit 100k set firewall policer test-policer-1002 if-exceeding burst-size-limit 3125 set firewall policer test-policer-1002 then discard set firewall policer test-policer-1003 if-exceeding bandwidth-limit 100k set firewall policer test-policer-1003 if-exceeding burst-size-limit 3125 set firewall policer test-policer-1003 then discard set firewall policer test-policer-1004 if-exceeding bandwidth-limit 100k set firewall policer test-policer-1004 if-exceeding burst-size-limit 3125 set firewall policer test-policer-1004 then discard {master:0} agould@eng-lab-5048-2> show configuration interfaces ge-0/0/19 | display set set interfaces ge-0/0/19 flexible-vlan-tagging set interfaces ge-0/0/19 mtu 9216 set interfaces ge-0/0/19 encapsulation flexible-ethernet-services set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1000 description "TEST att mtso - tower 98 Drain 1 - vlan 1000" set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1000 encapsulation vlan-vpls set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1000 vlan-id 1000 set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1000 input-vlan-map pop set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1000 output-vlan-map push set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1000 statistics set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1000 family vpls policer input test-policer-1000 set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1001 description "TEST att mtso - tower 99 Drain 1 - vlan 1001" set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1001 encapsulation vlan-vpls set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1001 vlan-id 1001 set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1001 input-vlan-map pop set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1001 output-vlan-map push set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1001 statistics set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1001 family vpls policer input test-policer-1001 set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1002 description "TEST att mtso - tower 100 Drain 1 - vlan 1002" set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1002 encapsulation vlan-vpls set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1002 vlan-id 1002 set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1002 input-vlan-map pop set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1002 output-vlan-map push set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1002 statistics set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1002 family vpls policer input test-policer-1002 set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1003 description "TEST att mtso - tower 101 Drain 1 - vlan 1003" set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1003 encapsulation vlan-vpls set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1003 vlan-id 1003 set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1003 input-vlan-map pop set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1003 output-vlan-map push set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1003 statistics set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1003 family vpls policer input test-policer-1003 set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1004 description "TEST att mtso - tower 102 Drain 1 - vlan 1004" set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1004 encapsulation vlan-vpls set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1004 vlan-id 1004 set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1004 input-vlan-map pop set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1004 output-vlan-map push set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1004 statistics set interfaces ge-0/0/19 unit 1004 family vpls policer input test-policer-1004 -----Original Message----- From: Erik Sundberg [mailto:ESundberg@nitelusa.com] Sent: Friday, April 14, 2017 10:30 AM To: Aaron Gould <aaron1@gvtc.com>; nanog@nanog.org Subject: RE: 10G MetroE 1-2U Switch Aaron, Do you know if the ACS5048 has any QOS limitations on this platform? Is each EVC on a ENNI able to have a separate QOS policy or is it port based? Just wondering how it would compare to the Cisco NCS5001\NCS5501 Thanks Erik Erik Sundberg Sr. Network Engineering Network Engineering Department p: 773.661.5532 c: 708.710.7419 e: esundberg@nitelusa.com Main: 888.450.2100 NOC 24/7: 866.892.0915 350 North Orleans Street, Suite 1300N Chicago, IL 60654 www.nitelusa.com Managed Telecom Services MPLS | Ethernet | Private Line | Internet | Voice | Security