Woody, Actually I'm pretty well aware of IXPs in general, having been a peering coordinator - I'm doing some specific research for enterprises on exchanges that are along the lines of Equinix Direct, XPE, or Band-X, to name a few. In general, enterprises are not willing to peer the way that ISPs are - that is, show up, and try to get some peering in a speculative fashion. Most are more comfortable showing up at a site with the expectation to pay, and a good idea of exactly who they can pay to get the services they need (basically, transit, not peering). They also tend to want centralized accounting, and sometimes a route server and a high degree of technical assistance are helpful. The average IXP does not even come close to meeting these requirements, sadly. We are starting to see more and more enterprises move into colocation spaces that have been traditionally ISP or carrier - the telcom hotels. Many of these enterprises want an easy way to pick up transit while they are there with minimum fuss. So far, I'm a bit surprised about how few folks are doing this. London seems to be a bright spot, having several providers of this sort of service. Equinix is also leading the way in Ashburn and San Jose. If anyone know of any providers offering this services in the NYC area, it would be helpful... - Dan
From: Bill Woodcock <woody@pch.net> Date: Wed, 8 Oct 2003 07:51:54 -0700 (PDT) To: Daniel Golding <dgolding@burtongroup.com> Cc: nanog@merit.edu Subject: Re: Transit and Paid Peering Exchanges
On Wed, 8 Oct 2003, Daniel Golding wrote:
Anyone have a list of Transit and Paid Peering exchange fabrics?
Very few exchanges place any restriction upon the private commercial arrangements between participants, any more. There are a few which actively promote transit use, like ExchangePoint.
You might be better served by simply compiling a list of exchanges you'd actually like to be at, and then checking to see if they have any policies which preclude what you want to do, and then checking those to see whether they're actually enforced, or whether those policies are on their way out.
-Bill