On Wed, Mar 16, 2011 at 2:48 PM, Jeff Aitken <jaitken@aitken.com> wrote:
On Wed, Mar 16, 2011 at 09:14:13AM -0700, andrew.wallace wrote:
This isn't the rhetoric of a super power, more like one of a university campus. [...] It strikes me straight away as amateurish to be blocking web sites in able to have enough bandwidth for operational purposes.
On the contrary, it's entirely plausible that US forces assisting with the recovery are (1) using more communications resources than normal, and (2) relying on infrastructure that's operating in a degraded state due to fiber or power issues. If so, it's entirely reasonable to put limits on bandwidth-hungry but non-essential applications as a precautionary measure.
Here's an excerpt from http://www.nextgov.com/nextgov/ng_20110314_9111.php?oref=topnews:
Military units operating in Japan face bandwidth shortages and network limitations that inhibit communications and command and control, Defense sources told Nextgov. Misawa Air Base, located on the northeast tip of Honshu, warned its personnel on a blog post Friday that the Defense Switched Network, which handles voice calls, was in backup mode and had only limited capacity, a fact confirmed by a Pentagon source Monday.
The blog post added, "We have a number of connectivity issues. Internet has been up and down due to our connections through other places in Japan. For example, Yokota [Air Base] and several other locations are having issues because we all have power and connectivity issues right now."
The Pentagon also took the extraordinary step of blocking access to a range of commercial websites to ensure that its networks have enough bandwidth to support mission-essential communications, Nextgov learned. This move, a military source told Nextgov, possibly indicates one or more undersea cables used by military networks were damaged by the earthquake.
--Jeff
Here's the problem with the logic of blocking all of the most popular sites; they tried this from time to time in Afghanistan on the NIPRnet. Whenever someone was unable to get to YouTube, Facebook, etc. they, still bored and/or wasting time, simply went to some other web site which also wasted equally as much bandwidth. -- Jeffrey Lyon, Leadership Team jeffrey.lyon@blacklotus.net | http://www.blacklotus.net Black Lotus Communications - AS32421 First and Leading in DDoS Protection Solutions