I am wanting to configure a secondary ISP to be used as fail over only for our primary. At this point both ISP's come into the same 7500 router and I have an established BGP session with our primary provider. Can those of you doing this already tell me the optimum way to set this up? Is this best done on my end or by having my secondary discover our disappearance and begin announcing? New territory for me so BGP configuration examples are welcome. Regards, Mike Stubbers Network Analyst Supervisor, SCP Information Technology Services University of Idaho mikest@uidaho.edu
Two very good guides for this: http://www.nanog.org/mtg-0110/ppt/smith.pdf and http://www.cisco.com/public/cons/isp/documents/Multihoming_Draft_2_0.PDF and basically all the documents in http://www.cisco.com/public/cons/isp/documents are worth the read. Enjoy. At 11:46 AM 1/18/2002, Mike Stubbers wrote:
I am wanting to configure a secondary ISP to be used as fail over only for our primary. At this point both ISP's come into the same 7500 router and I have an established BGP session with our primary provider.
Can those of you doing this already tell me the optimum way to set this up? Is this best done on my end or by having my secondary discover our disappearance and begin announcing?
New territory for me so BGP configuration examples are welcome.
Regards,
Mike Stubbers Network Analyst Supervisor, SCP Information Technology Services University of Idaho mikest@uidaho.edu
-tdawson -Network Geek (Bit Pusher) -BlueMartini Software
Hows it going, Travis? A much more worthwhile read for a beginner, not that I mind slogging through CCO, is Avi Freedman's intro to BGP at: http://www.netaxs.com/~freedman/bgp/bgp.html matto On Fri, 18 Jan 2002, Travis Dawson wrote: Two very good guides for this: http://www.nanog.org/mtg-0110/ppt/smith.pdf and http://www.cisco.com/public/cons/isp/documents/Multihoming_Draft_2_0.PDF and basically all the documents in http://www.cisco.com/public/cons/isp/documents are worth the read. Enjoy. --mghali@snark.net------------------------------------------<darwin>< Flowers on the razor wire/I know you're here/We are few/And far between/I was thinking about her skin/Love is a many splintered thing/Don't be afraid now/Just walk on in. #include <disclaim.h>
On Friday 18 January 2002, at 11 h 46, "Mike Stubbers" <mikest@uidaho.edu> wrote:
I am wanting to configure a secondary ISP to be used as fail over only for our primary.
Most people who have two links use them also for load-sharing. A link to an ISP is expensive enough so you don't want to keep it unused "just in case". Is it because the second ISP charges a lot according to the volume actually transfered?
At this point both ISP's come into the same 7500 router
So much for the redundancy.
have an established BGP session with our primary provider.
Do you have a private AS number or already a public one?
Can those of you doing this already tell me the optimum way to set this up? Is this best done on my end or by having my secondary discover our disappearance and begin announcing?
I would say that it is better done on your end because it will allow you to change your policy (see above my remarks). Also, it is "the normal way" of operation for BGP.
-----Original Message----- Stephane Bortzmeyer To: Mike Stubbers
On Friday 18 January 2002, at 11 h 46, "Mike Stubbers" <mikest@uidaho.edu> wrote:
I am wanting to configure a secondary ISP to be used as fail over only for our primary. Most people who have two links use them also for load-sharing. A link to an ISP is expensive enough so you don't want to keep it unused "just in case". Is it because the second ISP charges a lot according to the volume actually transfered?
At this point both ISP's come into the same 7500 router. So much for
Given our rural location, the high cost is in the circuit not the service. We have contracted with a local ISP to utilize their bandwidth, but they do not have continued capacity to support load balancing effectively. When our primary fails we understand our secondary will become saturated as well upstream. Not a pretty solution, but affordable for the moment. So yes, we need to use this as backup only. The pricing model has this built in. We'll pay very little to have the reserve in place, but face penalties when utilized. the redundancy. Agreed, see affordable note above. Historically most of our outages have come from a local farmer during spring work, or a redneck with a shotgun. I can repurpose equipment as needed in an emergency.
have an established BGP session with our primary provider. Do you have a private AS number or already a public one?
We have a public AS in place already.
Can those of you doing this already tell me the optimum way to set this up? Is this best done on my end or by having my secondary discover our disappearance and begin announcing?
I would say that it is better done on your end because it will allow you to change your policy (see above my remarks). Also, it is "the normal way" of operation for BGP.
Thanks for your input.
participants (4)
-
just me -
Mike Stubbers -
Stephane Bortzmeyer -
Travis Dawson