They are responsible for writing the correct import/export policies for their network, just like the carriers for writing sane policies for customer circuits

Nobody is asserting that operators are still not responsible for doing this. Stop it. 

What I think some of you guys fail to understand is that you can have perfectly appropriate policy protections in place that the prefixes generated by the optimizer can still bypass, because these devices don't follow standard BGP behaviors. This has happened before. 





On Thu, Dec 5, 2024 at 5:37 PM Ryan Hamel <ryan@rkhtech.org> wrote:
Warren,
  • "Guns don't kill people, people with guns kill people" may be a factually true statement - but if there were no guns, there would be less people being shot…
While that is also a factually true statement, you are also painting broad strokes over those who are responsible with those weapons. Employment requirements, hunting season, target practice at a range, skeet shooting, are just a few reasons to have them. Let's not dismiss those who follow the law, get qualified on a regular basis or have adequate training when/where/why/how to properly use them.

"One rotten apple spoils the whole bunch", does not work here.

This same thing also applies to operators of route optimizers. They are responsible for writing the correct import/export policies for their network, just like the carriers for writing sane policies for customer circuits. For the incidents those route optimizers have caused, the vendors, their customers, and upstream ISPs are still in business.

Ryan Hamel


From: NANOG <nanog-bounces+ryan=rkhtech.org@nanog.org> on behalf of Warren Kumari <warren@kumari.net>
Sent: Thursday, December 5, 2024 1:17 PM
To: Mike Hammett <nanog@ics-il.net>
Cc: nanog@nanog.org <nanog@nanog.org>
Subject: Re: Route optimization using GPUs?
 
Caution: This is an external email and may be malicious. Please take care when clicking links or opening attachments.





On Thu, Dec 05, 2024 at 3:41 PM, Mike Hammett <nanog@ics-il.net> wrote:
*shrugs* Incorrectly assigning the blame doesn't really help anyone.


Sure, but the fact remains that there is blame to be assigned. 

It doesn't really matter to the affected network if the fault lies with the box itself, or the operator of the box, or the person who makes the morning coffee for the person who operates the box — the fact still remains that this call of devices have caused significant disruption for a whole bunch of external networks.

"Guns don't kill people, people with guns kill people" may be a factually true statement - but if there were no guns, there would be less people being shot…
"Route optimizers don't hijack routes, operators with route optimizers hijack routes" falls into the same category…

W




-----
Mike Hammett
Intelligent Computing Solutions
http://www.ics-il.com

Midwest-IX
http://www.midwest-ix.com

From: "Tom Beecher" <beecher@beecher.cc>
To: "Mike Hammett" <nanog@ics-il.net>
Cc: "Rich Compton" <RICH_COMPTON@comcast.com>, nanog@nanog.org
Sent: Thursday, December 5, 2024 2:39:52 PM
Subject: Re: Route optimization using GPUs?

I think most of the hatred towards them is unwarranted,

This is essentially saying "I've never had a problem , so I don't think it's a big deal."

On Thu, Dec 5, 2024 at 3:19 PM Mike Hammett <nanog@ics-il.net> wrote:
Eh, different people have different opinions.

I think most of the hatred towards them is unwarranted,



-----
Mike Hammett
Intelligent Computing Solutions
http://www.ics-il.com

Midwest-IX
http://www.midwest-ix.com

From: "Rich Compton" <RICH_COMPTON@comcast.com>
To: "Mike Hammett" <nanog@ics-il.net>, "Jason Bothe" <jbothe@me.com>
Cc: nanog@nanog.org
Sent: Thursday, December 5, 2024 2:10:47 PM
Subject: Re: Route optimization using GPUs?

“I strongly recommend to turn off those BGP optimizers, glue the ports shut, burn the hardware, and salt the grounds on which the BGP optimizer sales people walked.”

 

-Job Snijders

 

https://mailman.nanog.org/pipermail/nanog/2017-August/092131.html

 

 

From: NANOG <nanog-bounces+rich_compton=comcast.com@nanog.org> on behalf of Mike Hammett <nanog@ics-il.net>
Date: Thursday, December 5, 2024 at 12:24 PM
To: Jason Bothe <jbothe@me.com>
Cc: nanog@nanog.org <nanog@nanog.org>
Subject: Re: Route optimization using GPUs?

IIRC, the widespread outages are the result of exporting things that shouldn't be exported.



-----
Mike Hammett
Intelligent Computing Solutions
http://www.ics-il.com

Midwest-IX
http://www.midwest-ix.com

 


From: "Jason Bothe via NANOG" <nanog@nanog.org>
To: "Drew Weaver" <drew.weaver@thenap.com>
Cc: nanog@nanog.org
Sent: Thursday, December 5, 2024 11:03:39 AM
Subject: Re: Route optimization using GPUs?

WIth merchant silicon getting faster and stronger everyday, and capacity and transit in a freewill, I’m not sure what GPU optimization would buy you, not to mention the ROI. The Internet routing table is not showing substantial signs of growth and in some cases has experienced a plateau. Also, the experience with ‘route optimization tools’ is that while they may bring you some priority in your traffic, they are also known for making horrible decisions resulting in widespread outages. 

 

J~

 

 

On Dec 5, 2024, at 8:13 AM, Drew Weaver <drew.weaver@thenap.com> wrote:

 

So back in the.. hell I don’t know like… early 2010s there was a push for ‘route optimization’ from products like RouteScience and the Avaya CNA and more recently whatever Noction is doing.

 

The big pain point for this technology at the time was that it could only optimize the top N egress routes due to how many probes it could send out and how many results it could process.

 

It seems like now with a modest GPU in a router you could pretty easily ‘optimize’ [to the extent that you believe this technology worked] pretty much the whole routing table.

 

We used these tools extensively back then and they actually worked pretty well in most cases. The biggest issue we ran into was people complaining that we pinged their IP addresses… which now a days seems like a great worst problem to have.

 

Anyway is anyone doing any work on implementing GPUs into the BGP decision making process? Seems like a no brainer.

 

-Drew